ISSN 0439-755X
CN 11-1911/B
主办:中国心理学会
   中国科学院心理研究所
出版:科学出版社

心理学报 ›› 2023, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (11): 1889-1902.doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1041.2023.01889

• 理论与史 • 上一篇    

延展心智:脑是实现心智的唯一基础吗?

苏佳佳1, 叶浩生1,2()   

  1. 1浙江师范大学心理学院, 金华 321004
    2广州大学具身认知研究中心, 广州 510006
  • 收稿日期:2023-02-06 发布日期:2023-08-30 出版日期:2023-11-25
  • 通讯作者: 叶浩生, E-mail: yehaosheng@gzhu.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金后期资助重点项目“身体运动与心理发展研究”(20FTYA002)

Extended mind: Is the brain the only basis for realizing the mind?

SU Jiajia1, YE Haosheng1,2()   

  1. 1School of Psychology, Zhejiang Normal University, Jinhua 321004, China
    2Center for Embodied Cognition, Guangzhou University, Guangzhou 510006, China
  • Received:2023-02-06 Online:2023-08-30 Published:2023-11-25

摘要:

当今时代, 人类正处于科学技术试图催生新文明的前夜。互联网、计算机和智能手机等科技将人类的认知能力延伸到机器之中, 甚至改变了人类的情感和意识体验, 使得人们逐渐接受“心理生活并不局限于脑”这样一种信念。这引发了人们对“延展心智”问题的关注。延展心智曾经主张, 记忆、思维、情绪和情感等心理过程并非局限于有机体的脑或中枢神经系统。相反, 在某些条件下, 有机体非神经部分的身体、身体之外的环境和世界都是实现心智的有效成分, 发挥了构成性的功用。早期的延展心智研究集中于认知过程的探讨, 经历了三波浪潮; 后来又扩展到延展情感, 探讨了情绪和情感的延展属性。近期, 意识体验是否可延展引发了人们的关注。如果认知、情感和意识体验都可超越个体的生物疆界, 包含实现心智过程的外部资源, 那么, 心理生活可能就不再囿于头颅和皮肤, 脑也并非实现心理生活的唯一器官。实际上, 延展心智依然是建立在具身认知的理论之上, 关键是如何看待“身体”的主动作用。这对于我们重新认识心理生活的本质具有重要启发意义。

关键词: 心理生活, 延展心智, 延展认知, 延展情感, 延展意识

Abstract:

Today, society is experiencing an era of rapid development in science and technology. Information technologies, such as the Internet, computers, and smart phones have significantly expanded human cognitive abilities and changed human emotional experiences, making people gradually accept the belief that memory and thinking are not limited to the brain. This has raised concerns about the problem of the so-called ‘extended mind’. The extended mind thesis maintains that mental processes such as memory, thinking, emotions, and affection are not confined to the brain or central nervous system of an organism, nor is the brain the only organ of the mind. On the contrary, under proper conditions, the organism’s non-neural body, the environment outside the body, and objects in the environment all play a constitutive role in mental activities. The early extended mind research focused on cognitive process, and has undergone three waves of development.
In recent years, research has begun to focus on extended emotions. The most basic manifestation of extended emotion is the dependence of emotional experience on the body. It is argued that emotional experience transcends the boundaries of the head and extends to the non-nervous body, known as the hypothesis of bodily extended emotions. In addition, extended emotion holds that the carrier of emotion not only exists in the organism, but also transcends the boundary of skin and contains external resources carrying emotions; this is known as the hypothesis of environmentally extended emotions. Emotions are individual regardless of whether they are physically or environmentally extended. However, in many conditions, emotions are not individual, but achieved through multiple people. In such cases, the emotion is shared by two or more individuals at the same time, the so-called hypothesis of socially extended emotions.
The significance from cognitive to emotional extension is that the entire mental process of human beings, including human conscious experience, can transcend the boundaries of the head and skin and extend to the external resources available in the environment. This is known as the extended consciousness thesis.
From cognitive, to emotional, and to consciousness extension, mental life transcends the Cartesian gap and straddles the mind, the body, and the environment. The mind transcends the boundaries of the skull and skin, that is, the place of the mind is not entirely confined to the brain, and the latter is not the only basis of the former.
Does mental life have no boundary with the objective world? Can mental life spread infinitely into every aspect of the universe? When we say that the subject and the world are a whole and inseparable, it does not mean that there is no difference between them, nor does it mean that there is no boundary in the mental life. However, the boundary of mental life is not ontological, but epistemological, similar to the Markov blanket concept that exists only statistically.
Extended mind thesis shows that cognition, emotion and even consciousness can break the boundaries of the brain and extend into the body and the environment. The cognitive boundaries, like a “Markov blanket”, are epistemologically malleable, depending entirely on how the organism chooses meaningful external resources to establish a coupled cognitive system with. In this sense, the extended mind is bound to be built on the theory of embodied cognition, that is, cognition is a trinity dynamic system in which the brain is embedded in the body and the body is embedded in the environment, and the “body” plays an active role.

Key words: mental life, extended mind, extended cognition, extended emotion, extended consciousness

中图分类号: