Advances in Psychological Science ›› 2026, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (11): 2003-2018.doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1042.2026.2003
• Meta-Analysis • Previous Articles Next Articles
LIU Wumei1, LI Yue1(
), LI Lingbo2, ZHANG Haitao1
Received:2025-06-26
Online:2026-11-15
Published:2026-08-21
Contact:
LI Yue
E-mail:liliy0103@163.com
CLC Number:
LIU Wumei, LI Yue, LI Lingbo, ZHANG Haitao. Antecedents and consequences of consumers' perception of product naturalness: A meta-analysis[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(11): 2003-2018.
| 变量 | 定义 | 代表性研究 | 具体纳入变量(部分) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 启发式线索: | |||
| 环境类型 | 可以通过感官线索和情境元素传递较强天然感的场所 | Lunardo & Saintives, | 购买点类型(超市vs.传统集市)、愉悦且具有天然属性的声音环境、具有天然属性的气味环境 |
| 声明 | 权威机构认证的, 表明该产品天然的证明 | Berry et al., | 纯天然声明(无vs.有)、天然认证标签(无vs.有)、自然性宣称的突出程度(低vs高) |
| 感官信息 | 产品外观展示出来的文字、图案和颜色等信息 | Szocs et al., | 包装色彩饱和度、有包装vs.无包装、食品形状(对称vs.不对称)、产品美学风格(表现型vs.经典型) |
| 系统式线索: | |||
| 生产要素 | 产品生产规模、加工流程等信息; 产品所含成分数量、类别及描述方式等 | Scekic & Krishna, | 配料种类数量、成分添加vs.去除、生产方式(手工vs.机械)、化学变化vs.物理变化 |
| 消费者反应: | |||
| 产品态度 | 消费者对产品的整体评价 | Fatemi & Wan, | 品牌态度、安全性感知、健康感知、感知质量、产品信任度、工具性优势 |
| 产品选择行为/意愿 | 消费者对产品的购买、推荐及采纳等具体行动或意愿 | Scekic & Krishna, | 购买意愿、推荐意愿、支付意愿、绿色购买意愿、采纳意愿、购买行为 |
| 变量 | 定义 | 代表性研究 | 具体纳入变量(部分) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 启发式线索: | |||
| 环境类型 | 可以通过感官线索和情境元素传递较强天然感的场所 | Lunardo & Saintives, | 购买点类型(超市vs.传统集市)、愉悦且具有天然属性的声音环境、具有天然属性的气味环境 |
| 声明 | 权威机构认证的, 表明该产品天然的证明 | Berry et al., | 纯天然声明(无vs.有)、天然认证标签(无vs.有)、自然性宣称的突出程度(低vs高) |
| 感官信息 | 产品外观展示出来的文字、图案和颜色等信息 | Szocs et al., | 包装色彩饱和度、有包装vs.无包装、食品形状(对称vs.不对称)、产品美学风格(表现型vs.经典型) |
| 系统式线索: | |||
| 生产要素 | 产品生产规模、加工流程等信息; 产品所含成分数量、类别及描述方式等 | Scekic & Krishna, | 配料种类数量、成分添加vs.去除、生产方式(手工vs.机械)、化学变化vs.物理变化 |
| 消费者反应: | |||
| 产品态度 | 消费者对产品的整体评价 | Fatemi & Wan, | 品牌态度、安全性感知、健康感知、感知质量、产品信任度、工具性优势 |
| 产品选择行为/意愿 | 消费者对产品的购买、推荐及采纳等具体行动或意愿 | Scekic & Krishna, | 购买意愿、推荐意愿、支付意愿、绿色购买意愿、采纳意愿、购买行为 |
| 变量 | 定义 | 代表性研究 |
|---|---|---|
| 产品类型 | 实用品: 消费更具认知驱动性, 以工具性、功能性为核心, 旨在完成实际任务 | Batra & Ahtola, |
| 享乐品: 消费以情感性、感官体验为核心特征, 聚焦审美愉悦、感官享受、幻想与乐趣等 | ||
| 产品属性 | 食品: 指摄入、消化或直接身体应用而被消费, 以提供营养和能量等的产品 | Raghunathan et al., |
| 非食品: 指不以上述方式被身体摄入或直接应用的其他产品 | ||
| 环境威胁水平 | 指个体所处环境中对健康与安全造成潜在损害的客观风险强度, 反映外部环境因素对人身健康与生活质量的威胁程度 | Cohen et al., |
| 变量 | 定义 | 代表性研究 |
|---|---|---|
| 产品类型 | 实用品: 消费更具认知驱动性, 以工具性、功能性为核心, 旨在完成实际任务 | Batra & Ahtola, |
| 享乐品: 消费以情感性、感官体验为核心特征, 聚焦审美愉悦、感官享受、幻想与乐趣等 | ||
| 产品属性 | 食品: 指摄入、消化或直接身体应用而被消费, 以提供营养和能量等的产品 | Raghunathan et al., |
| 非食品: 指不以上述方式被身体摄入或直接应用的其他产品 | ||
| 环境威胁水平 | 指个体所处环境中对健康与安全造成潜在损害的客观风险强度, 反映外部环境因素对人身健康与生活质量的威胁程度 | Cohen et al., |
| 变量 | K | N | ρ | 95%置信区间 | 双尾检验 | Qw | I2 | Begg检验显著性 | 失安全系数 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 下限 | 上限 | Z | P | |||||||||
| 前因变量 | ||||||||||||
| 感官信息 | 40 | 10001 | −0.282 | 0.215 | 0.346 | 7.98 | 0.000 | 478.64*** | 91.85 | 0.056 | 6452 | |
| 声明 | 29 | 16990 | 0.210 | 0.159 | 0.259 | 8.01 | 0.000 | 258.28*** | 89.16 | 0.081 | 2325 | |
| 消费环境类型 | 23 | 8098 | 0.299 | 0.169 | 0.419 | 4.39 | 0.000 | 845.24*** | 97.40 | 0.178 | 3349 | |
| 生产要素 | 42 | 16970 | −0.446 | 0.346 | 0.536 | 7.90 | 0.000 | 2335.46*** | 98.24 | 0.077 | 29291 | |
| 结果变量 | ||||||||||||
| 消费者反应 | 95 | 19339 | 0.310 | 0.270 | 0.349 | 14.31 | 0.000 | 855.75*** | 89.02 | 0.926 | 43459 | |
| 变量 | K | N | ρ | 95%置信区间 | 双尾检验 | Qw | I2 | Begg检验显著性 | 失安全系数 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 下限 | 上限 | Z | P | |||||||||
| 前因变量 | ||||||||||||
| 感官信息 | 40 | 10001 | −0.282 | 0.215 | 0.346 | 7.98 | 0.000 | 478.64*** | 91.85 | 0.056 | 6452 | |
| 声明 | 29 | 16990 | 0.210 | 0.159 | 0.259 | 8.01 | 0.000 | 258.28*** | 89.16 | 0.081 | 2325 | |
| 消费环境类型 | 23 | 8098 | 0.299 | 0.169 | 0.419 | 4.39 | 0.000 | 845.24*** | 97.40 | 0.178 | 3349 | |
| 生产要素 | 42 | 16970 | −0.446 | 0.346 | 0.536 | 7.90 | 0.000 | 2335.46*** | 98.24 | 0.077 | 29291 | |
| 结果变量 | ||||||||||||
| 消费者反应 | 95 | 19339 | 0.310 | 0.270 | 0.349 | 14.31 | 0.000 | 855.75*** | 89.02 | 0.926 | 43459 | |
| 变量 | 结果 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| β | SE | 95%lower | 95%upper | Z | P | VIF | |
| 产品因素调节 | |||||||
| 产品属性(0=非食物, 1=食物) | 0.108* | 0.050 | 0.010 | 0.205 | 2.16 | 0.031 | 1.36 |
| 产品类型(0=享乐品, 1=实用品) | 0.091* | 0.043 | 0.006 | 0.175 | 2.10 | 0.036 | 1.43 |
| 消费者因素调节 | |||||||
| 性别(女性比例) | 0.004* | 0.002 | 0.001 | 0.008 | 2.07 | 0.039 | 2.01 |
| 年龄 | 0.005 | 0.003 | −0.002 | 0.011 | 1.48 | 0.140 | 1.70 |
| 情境因素调节 | |||||||
| 环境威胁水平 | 0.004✝ | 0.003 | −0.001 | 0.009 | 1.78 | 0.075 | 1.64 |
| 结果类型(0=态度, 1=选择行为/意愿) | −0.098* | 0.043 | −0.182 | −0.014 | −2.27 | 0.023 | 1.36 |
| 控制变量 | |||||||
| 不确定性规避 | 0.003* | 0.002 | 0.001 | 0.006 | 2.07 | 0.039 | 1.96 |
| 被试类型(0=社会被试, 1=学生被试) | 0.109* | 0.053 | 0.006 | 0.213 | 2.07 | 0.038 | 1.41 |
| 发表状态(0=未发表, 1=已发表) | 0.017 | 0.086 | −0.151 | 0.184 | 0.19 | 0.846 | 1.65 |
| 重大公共卫生安全事件后发表(0=否, 1=是) | 0.108* | 0.054 | 0.002 | 0.213 | 2.00 | 0.045 | 2.09 |
| 变量 | 结果 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| β | SE | 95%lower | 95%upper | Z | P | VIF | |
| 产品因素调节 | |||||||
| 产品属性(0=非食物, 1=食物) | 0.108* | 0.050 | 0.010 | 0.205 | 2.16 | 0.031 | 1.36 |
| 产品类型(0=享乐品, 1=实用品) | 0.091* | 0.043 | 0.006 | 0.175 | 2.10 | 0.036 | 1.43 |
| 消费者因素调节 | |||||||
| 性别(女性比例) | 0.004* | 0.002 | 0.001 | 0.008 | 2.07 | 0.039 | 2.01 |
| 年龄 | 0.005 | 0.003 | −0.002 | 0.011 | 1.48 | 0.140 | 1.70 |
| 情境因素调节 | |||||||
| 环境威胁水平 | 0.004✝ | 0.003 | −0.001 | 0.009 | 1.78 | 0.075 | 1.64 |
| 结果类型(0=态度, 1=选择行为/意愿) | −0.098* | 0.043 | −0.182 | −0.014 | −2.27 | 0.023 | 1.36 |
| 控制变量 | |||||||
| 不确定性规避 | 0.003* | 0.002 | 0.001 | 0.006 | 2.07 | 0.039 | 1.96 |
| 被试类型(0=社会被试, 1=学生被试) | 0.109* | 0.053 | 0.006 | 0.213 | 2.07 | 0.038 | 1.41 |
| 发表状态(0=未发表, 1=已发表) | 0.017 | 0.086 | −0.151 | 0.184 | 0.19 | 0.846 | 1.65 |
| 重大公共卫生安全事件后发表(0=否, 1=是) | 0.108* | 0.054 | 0.002 | 0.213 | 2.00 | 0.045 | 2.09 |
| 前因变量 | K | N | ρ | 95%置信区间 | 双尾检验 | Qw | p | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 下限 | 上限 | Z | p | ||||||
| 启发式线索 | 92 | 35089 | 0.265 | 0.221 | 0.309 | 11.27 | 0.000 | 13.36 | 0.000 |
| 系统式线索 | 42 | 16970 | 0.470 | 0.373 | 0.557 | 8.42 | 0.000 | ||
| 前因变量 | K | N | ρ | 95%置信区间 | 双尾检验 | Qw | p | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 下限 | 上限 | Z | p | ||||||
| 启发式线索 | 92 | 35089 | 0.265 | 0.221 | 0.309 | 11.27 | 0.000 | 13.36 | 0.000 |
| 系统式线索 | 42 | 16970 | 0.470 | 0.373 | 0.557 | 8.42 | 0.000 | ||
| 序号 | 作者(年份) | 效应值r | 样本量 | 前因类别 | 产品类别 | 产品属性 | 女性比例 | 年龄 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Abouab ( | 0.51 | 69 | FP | ||||
| 2 | Abouab ( | 0.22 | 133 | FP | ||||
| 3 | Abouab ( | 0.28 | 133 | FP | ||||
| 4 | Amos ( | 0.67 | 109 | Food | UTP | 62.00 | 32.20 | |
| 5 | Amos ( | 0.39 | 132 | Food | UTP | 41.70 | 32.20 | |
| 6 | Amos ( | 0.28 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 7 | Amos ( | 0.22 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 8 | Amos ( | 0.23 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 9 | Amos ( | 0.28 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 10 | Amos ( | 0.29 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 11 | Amos ( | 0.25 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 12 | Amos ( | 0.19 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 13 | Amos ( | 0.25 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 14 | Amos ( | 0.20 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 15 | Amos ( | 0.22 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 16 | Amos ( | 0.27 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 17 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 18 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 19 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 20 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 21 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 22 | Amos ( | 0.23 | 126 | Food | UTP | 42.00 | 32.20 | |
| 23 | Amos ( | 0.21 | 123 | Nfood | UTP | 43.00 | 32.20 | |
| 24 | Amos ( | 0.16 | 125 | Nfood | UTP | 39.00 | 32.20 | |
| 25 | Berry ( | 0.54 | 140 | ND | ||||
| 26 | Berry ( | 0.49 | 161 | ND | ||||
| 27 | Berry ( | 0.19 | 161 | Food | UTP | 58.00 | 38.40 | |
| 28 | Berry ( | 0.26 | 161 | Food | UTP | 58.00 | 38.40 | |
| 29 | Chen ( | 0.89 | 144 | FP | ||||
| 30 | Chen ( | 0.27 | 810 | FP | ||||
| 31 | Chen ( | 0.23 | 209 | FP | ||||
| 32 | Chen ( | 0.18 | 219 | FP | ||||
| 33 | Chen ( | 0.19 | 224 | FP | ||||
| 34 | Chen ( | 0.28 | 364 | FP | ||||
| 35 | Chen ( | 0.11 | 401 | FP | ||||
| 36 | Chen ( | 0.33 | 72 | Nfood | HDP | 45.80 | 24.60 | |
| 37 | Chen ( | 0.33 | 176 | Nfood | HDP | 60.80 | 24.50 | |
| 38 | Chen ( | 0.43 | 184 | Nfood | HDP | 64.70 | 25.70 | |
| 39 | Chen ( | 0.47 | 216 | Nfood | HDP | 57.90 | 25.10 | |
| 40 | Chen ( | 0.96 | 61 | SI | ||||
| 41 | Chen ( | 0.44 | 448 | SI | ||||
| 42 | Cheng ( | 0.74 | 398 | TCE | ||||
| 43 | d’Astous ( | 0.12 | 120 | SI | ||||
| 44 | Du ( | 0.36 | 119 | Food | UTP | 53.80 | 33.25 | |
| 45 | Du ( | 0.20 | 150 | Food | UTP | 57.30 | 31.98 | |
| 46 | Du ( | 0.60 | 150 | Food | HDP | 57.30 | 31.98 | |
| 47 | Du ( | 0.46 | 210 | Food | UTP | 62.90 | 30.10 | |
| 48 | Du ( | 0.03 | 210 | Food | UTP | 62.90 | 30.10 | |
| 49 | Du ( | 0.39 | 238 | Food | UTP | 52.10 | 32.57 | |
| 50 | Du ( | 0.10 | 238 | Food | UTP | 52.10 | 32.57 | |
| 51 | Ercan et al.( | 0.02 | 150 | Nfood | HDP | 41.30 | 34.13 | |
| 52 | Esteky ( | 0.25 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 53 | Esteky ( | 0.18 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 54 | Esteky ( | 0.33 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 55 | Esteky ( | 0.19 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 56 | Esteky ( | 0.12 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 57 | Esteky ( | 0.25 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 58 | Esteky ( | 0.15 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 59 | Esteky ( | 0.35 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 60 | Esteky ( | 0.36 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 61 | Esteky ( | 0.39 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 62 | Etale ( | 0.33 | 503 | ND | ||||
| 63 | Etale ( | 0.43 | 503 | FP | ||||
| 64 | Evans ( | 0.76 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 65 | Evans ( | 0.81 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 66 | Evans ( | 0.62 | 190 | SI | ||||
| 67 | Evans ( | 0.34 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 68 | Evans ( | 0.40 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 69 | Evans ( | 0.43 | 190 | SI | ||||
| 70 | Evans ( | 0.27 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 71 | Fischer & Hilboesen( | 0.08 | 449 | FP | ||||
| 72 | Fischer & Hilboesen( | 0.33 | 449 | FP | ||||
| 73 | Evans ( | 0.38 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 74 | Fatemi ( | 0.47 | 47 | Food | HDP | 50.00 | 24.00 | |
| 75 | Fatemi ( | 0.24 | 276 | Nfood | HDP | 60.00 | 35.00 | |
| 76 | He et al. ( | −0.23 | 202 | SI | ||||
| 77 | He et al. ( | 0.39 | 202 | Nfood | UTP | 46.00 | 35.86 | |
| 78 | Hooge ( | 0.05 | 1099 | Food | UTP | 45.00 | 41.63 | |
| 79 | Hu et al.( | 0.21 | 170 | SI | ||||
| 80 | Hu et al.( | 0.25 | 150 | SI | ||||
| 81 | Hu et al.( | 0.22 | 200 | SI | ||||
| 82 | Hu et al.( | 0.22 | 200 | Food | HDP | 64.50 | 31.30 | |
| 83 | Hu et al.( | 0.06 | 230 | SI | ||||
| 84 | Hu et al.( | 0.23 | 230 | SI | ||||
| 85 | Huang et al.( | 0.56 | 120 | Food | HDP | 50.80 | 30.54 | |
| 86 | Huang et al.( | 0.17 | 270 | Food | UTP | 46.70 | 36.49 | |
| 87 | Huang et al.( | 0.15 | 270 | Food | HDP | 46.70 | 36.49 | |
| 88 | Kumar ( | 0.27 | 501 | SI | ||||
| 89 | Kumar ( | 0.41 | 720 | TCE | ||||
| 90 | Lähteenmäki ( | 0.03 | 4612 | ND | ||||
| 91 | Lähteenmäki ( | 0.30 | 4612 | FP | ||||
| 92 | Lähteenmäki ( | 0.04 | 4612 | ND | ||||
| 93 | Li ( | 0.60 | 447 | Nfood | UTP | 50.14 | 32.20 | |
| 94 | Li ( | 0.61 | 499 | Nfood | UTP | 50.14 | 46.42 | |
| 95 | Li ( | 0.18 | 124 | Nfood | UTP | 48.40 | 22.70 | |
| 96 | Li ( | 0.18 | 230 | Nfood | UTP | 47.40 | 27.60 | |
| 97 | Li ( | 0.18 | 170 | Nfood | UTP | 51.80 | 28.20 | |
| 98 | Li ( | 0.69 | 113 | SI | ||||
| 99 | Li ( | 0.40 | 307 | SI | ||||
| 100 | Li ( | 0.46 | 113 | SI | ||||
| 101 | Li et al.( | 0.21 | 174 | SI | ||||
| 102 | Li et al.( | 0.00 | 188 | SI | ||||
| 103 | Li et al.( | 0.23 | 309 | SI | ||||
| 104 | Li et al.( | 0.06 | 309 | SI | ||||
| 105 | Lunardo ( | 0.15 | 156 | ND | ||||
| 106 | Lunardo ( | 0.18 | 156 | TCE | ||||
| 107 | Lunardo ( | 0.48 | 169 | TCE | ||||
| 108 | Lunardo ( | 0.45 | 169 | ND | ||||
| 109 | Ma et al.( | 0.51 | 177 | Nfood | UTP | 50.00 | 21.70 | |
| 110 | Ma et al.( | 0.37 | 413 | Nfood | UTP | 49.00 | 33.40 | |
| 111 | Ma et al.( | 0.32 | 1700 | Nfood | UTP | 52.37 | 32.93 | |
| 112 | Ma et al.( | 0.51 | 177 | Nfood | UTP | 50.00 | 21.70 | |
| 113 | Ma et al.( | 0.36 | 177 | SI | ||||
| 114 | Ma et al.( | 0.25 | 413 | SI | ||||
| 115 | Ma et al.( | 0.37 | 413 | Nfood | UTP | 50.00 | 21.70 | |
| 116 | Ma et al.( | 0.20 | 1700 | SI | ||||
| 117 | Marckhgott ( | 0.41 | 136 | SI | ||||
| 118 | Margariti ( | 0.33 | 305 | ND | ||||
| 119 | Margariti ( | 0.41 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 120 | Margariti ( | 0.50 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 121 | Margariti ( | 0.46 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 122 | Margariti ( | 0.45 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 123 | Marozzo ( | 0.23 | 101 | Food | UTP | 53.50 | 33.18 | |
| 124 | Marozzo ( | 0.18 | 101 | Food | UTP | 53.50 | 33.18 | |
| 125 | Marozzo ( | 0.23 | 104 | Food | HDP | 62.50 | 30.98 | |
| 126 | Marozzo ( | 0.18 | 104 | Food | HDP | 62.50 | 30.98 | |
| 127 | Marozzo ( | 0.21 | 198 | Food | UTP | 38.90 | 34.78 | |
| 128 | Marozzo ( | 0.25 | 198 | Food | UTP | 39.90 | 34.78 | |
| 129 | Marozzo ( | 0.04 | 198 | Food | HDP | 62.50 | 30.98 | |
| 130 | Marozzo ( | 0.33 | 212 | Food | UTP | 50.00 | 35.86 | |
| 131 | Marozzo ( | 0.30 | 212 | Food | UTP | 50.00 | 35.86 | |
| 132 | Meier et al.( | 0.30 | 118 | Nfood | HDP | 80.00 | 21.92 | |
| 133 | Nitzko ( | 0.39 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 134 | Nitzko ( | 0.31 | 559 | FP | ||||
| 135 | Nitzko ( | 0.31 | 559 | FP | ||||
| 136 | Pichierri ( | 0.36 | 104 | SI | ||||
| 137 | Pichierri ( | 0.02 | 196 | SI | ||||
| 138 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.29 | 75 | ND | ||||
| 139 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.30 | 80 | ND | ||||
| 140 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.29 | 88 | ND | ||||
| 141 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.20 | 100 | ND | ||||
| 142 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.23 | 78 | ND | ||||
| 143 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.15 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 144 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.10 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 145 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.18 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 146 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.11 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 147 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.12 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 148 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.19 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 149 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.04 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 150 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.14 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 151 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.18 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 152 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.26 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 153 | Rozin ( | 0.66 | 97 | FP | ||||
| 154 | Rozin ( | 0.68 | 97 | FP | ||||
| 155 | Rozin ( | 0.56 | 99 | FP | ||||
| 156 | Rozin ( | 0.59 | 99 | FP | ||||
| 157 | Rozin ( | 0.13 | 99 | FP | ||||
| 158 | Saint-Eve et al.( | 0.96 | 64 | Food | HDP | 52.26 | 21.00 | |
| 159 | Scekic ( | 0.30 | 182 | FP | ||||
| 160 | Scekic ( | 0.06 | 285 | Nfood | UTP | 45.96 | 20.13 | |
| 161 | Scekic ( | 0.98 | 285 | FP | ||||
| 162 | Scekic ( | 0.57 | 285 | FP | ||||
| 163 | Scekic ( | 0.94 | 249 | FP | ||||
| 164 | Scott ( | 0.12 | 720 | TCE | ||||
| 165 | Siegrist ( | 0.64 | 588 | FP | ||||
| 166 | Siegrist ( | 0.67 | 183 | FP | ||||
| 167 | Siegrist ( | 0.19 | 244 | FP | ||||
| 168 | Siegrist ( | 0.22 | 244 | FP | ||||
| 169 | Siegrist ( | 0.69 | 253 | FP | ||||
| 170 | Siegrist ( | 0.55 | 253 | Food | UTP | 33.60 | 61.30 | |
| 171 | Staub ( | −0.09 | 486 | SI | ||||
| 172 | Staub ( | 0.14 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 173 | Staub ( | 0.13 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 174 | Staub ( | 0.12 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 175 | Staub ( | 0.09 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 176 | Staub ( | 0.59 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 177 | Steiner et al.(2026) | 0.29 | 559 | FP | ||||
| 178 | Steiner et al.(2026) | 0.13 | 261 | SI | ||||
| 179 | Stoltze ( | 0.09 | 497 | ND | ||||
| 180 | Stoltze ( | 0.35 | 497 | ND | ||||
| 181 | Stoltze ( | 0.09 | 497 | ND | ||||
| 182 | Szocs ( | 0.38 | 150 | SI | ||||
| 183 | Szocs ( | 0.00 | 100 | SI | ||||
| 184 | Szocs ( | 0.23 | 240 | SI | ||||
| 185 | Szocs ( | 0.19 | 300 | SI | ||||
| 186 | Szocs ( | 0.19 | 200 | SI | ||||
| 187 | Szocs ( | 0.22 | 300 | SI | ||||
| 188 | Szocs ( | 0.31 | 100 | SI | ||||
| 189 | Tenbült ( | −0.31 | 1400 | TCE | ||||
| 190 | Tsai et al.( | 0.22 | 100 | Nfood | HDP | 54.00 | 38.78 | |
| 191 | Wang (2022) | 0.27 | 138 | Food | UTP | 57.20 | 29.91 | |
| 192 | Wang (2022) | 0.53 | 137 | Food | UTP | 52.60 | 29.52 | |
| 193 | Wang (2022) | 0.38 | 113 | Food | UTP | 66.40 | 28.01 | |
| 194 | Wang ( | 0.43 | 162 | SI | ||||
| 195 | Wang ( | 0.37 | 162 | SI | ||||
| 196 | Wang ( | 0.26 | 165 | SI | ||||
| 197 | Wang et al.( | 0.35 | 407 | Food | HDP | 48.65 | 33.20 | |
| 198 | Xu ( | 0.42 | 200 | Food | HDP | 61.50 | 31.80 | |
| 199 | Yang ( | 0.26 | 216 | Food | UTP | 65.20 | 32.20 | |
| 200 | Yang ( | 0.22 | 216 | Food | UTP | 65.20 | 32.20 | |
| 201 | Yang ( | 0.42 | 227 | TCE | ||||
| 202 | Zhang ( | 0.17 | 142 | SI | ||||
| 203 | Zhang ( | 0.03 | 153 | SI | ||||
| 204 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.20 | 170 | ND | ||||
| 205 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.57 | 170 | Food | UTP | 74.70 | 32.08 | |
| 206 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.38 | 170 | Food | UTP | 74.70 | 32.08 | |
| 207 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.07 | 260 | ND | ||||
| 208 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.30 | 260 | ND | ||||
| 209 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.19 | 260 | Food | UTP | 64.60 | 31.93 | |
| 210 | Zhu & Jin (2025) | 0.40 | 149 | SI | ||||
| 211 | 陈婷婷 (2021) | −0.42 | 216 | Food | HDP | 57.90 | 25.10 | |
| 212 | 陈婷婷 (2021) | −0.32 | 216 | Food | HDP | 57.90 | 25.10 | |
| 213 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.33 | 72 | Nfood | HDP | 45.80 | 24.60 | |
| 214 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.34 | 86 | Food | UTP | 53.50 | 24.80 | |
| 215 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.28 | 88 | Food | UTP | 68.20 | 24.20 | |
| 216 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.44 | 184 | Nfood | UTP | 64.70 | 25.70 | |
| 217 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.48 | 208 | Nfood | UTP | 100.00 | 25.90 | |
| 218 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.41 | 264 | Food | HDP | 60.20 | 24.20 | |
| 219 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.14 | 206 | Nfood | HDP | 61.70 | 24.20 | |
| 220 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.21 | 198 | TCE | ||||
| 221 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.19 | 238 | TCE | ||||
| 222 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.73 | 249 | TCE | ||||
| 223 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.21 | 421 | TCE | ||||
| 224 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.17 | 228 | TCE | ||||
| 225 | 朱培 ( | −0.21 | 120 | Nfood | UTP | 62.50 | 28.80 | |
| 226 | 朱培 ( | −0.22 | 170 | Food | HDP | 65.90 | 28.54 | |
| 227 | 朱培 ( | −0.16 | 160 | Nfood | HDP | 74.40 | 30.20 | |
| 228 | 朱培 ( | −0.15 | 270 | Food | HDP | 68.90 | 30.20 | |
| 229 | 朱培 ( | 0.37 | 100 | Nfood | HDP | 66.00 | 25.60 |
| 序号 | 作者(年份) | 效应值r | 样本量 | 前因类别 | 产品类别 | 产品属性 | 女性比例 | 年龄 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Abouab ( | 0.51 | 69 | FP | ||||
| 2 | Abouab ( | 0.22 | 133 | FP | ||||
| 3 | Abouab ( | 0.28 | 133 | FP | ||||
| 4 | Amos ( | 0.67 | 109 | Food | UTP | 62.00 | 32.20 | |
| 5 | Amos ( | 0.39 | 132 | Food | UTP | 41.70 | 32.20 | |
| 6 | Amos ( | 0.28 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 7 | Amos ( | 0.22 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 8 | Amos ( | 0.23 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 9 | Amos ( | 0.28 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 10 | Amos ( | 0.29 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 11 | Amos ( | 0.25 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 12 | Amos ( | 0.19 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 13 | Amos ( | 0.25 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 14 | Amos ( | 0.20 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 15 | Amos ( | 0.22 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 16 | Amos ( | 0.27 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 17 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 18 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 19 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 20 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 21 | Amos ( | 0.18 | 100 | Food | HDP | 31.00 | 32.20 | |
| 22 | Amos ( | 0.23 | 126 | Food | UTP | 42.00 | 32.20 | |
| 23 | Amos ( | 0.21 | 123 | Nfood | UTP | 43.00 | 32.20 | |
| 24 | Amos ( | 0.16 | 125 | Nfood | UTP | 39.00 | 32.20 | |
| 25 | Berry ( | 0.54 | 140 | ND | ||||
| 26 | Berry ( | 0.49 | 161 | ND | ||||
| 27 | Berry ( | 0.19 | 161 | Food | UTP | 58.00 | 38.40 | |
| 28 | Berry ( | 0.26 | 161 | Food | UTP | 58.00 | 38.40 | |
| 29 | Chen ( | 0.89 | 144 | FP | ||||
| 30 | Chen ( | 0.27 | 810 | FP | ||||
| 31 | Chen ( | 0.23 | 209 | FP | ||||
| 32 | Chen ( | 0.18 | 219 | FP | ||||
| 33 | Chen ( | 0.19 | 224 | FP | ||||
| 34 | Chen ( | 0.28 | 364 | FP | ||||
| 35 | Chen ( | 0.11 | 401 | FP | ||||
| 36 | Chen ( | 0.33 | 72 | Nfood | HDP | 45.80 | 24.60 | |
| 37 | Chen ( | 0.33 | 176 | Nfood | HDP | 60.80 | 24.50 | |
| 38 | Chen ( | 0.43 | 184 | Nfood | HDP | 64.70 | 25.70 | |
| 39 | Chen ( | 0.47 | 216 | Nfood | HDP | 57.90 | 25.10 | |
| 40 | Chen ( | 0.96 | 61 | SI | ||||
| 41 | Chen ( | 0.44 | 448 | SI | ||||
| 42 | Cheng ( | 0.74 | 398 | TCE | ||||
| 43 | d’Astous ( | 0.12 | 120 | SI | ||||
| 44 | Du ( | 0.36 | 119 | Food | UTP | 53.80 | 33.25 | |
| 45 | Du ( | 0.20 | 150 | Food | UTP | 57.30 | 31.98 | |
| 46 | Du ( | 0.60 | 150 | Food | HDP | 57.30 | 31.98 | |
| 47 | Du ( | 0.46 | 210 | Food | UTP | 62.90 | 30.10 | |
| 48 | Du ( | 0.03 | 210 | Food | UTP | 62.90 | 30.10 | |
| 49 | Du ( | 0.39 | 238 | Food | UTP | 52.10 | 32.57 | |
| 50 | Du ( | 0.10 | 238 | Food | UTP | 52.10 | 32.57 | |
| 51 | Ercan et al.( | 0.02 | 150 | Nfood | HDP | 41.30 | 34.13 | |
| 52 | Esteky ( | 0.25 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 53 | Esteky ( | 0.18 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 54 | Esteky ( | 0.33 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 55 | Esteky ( | 0.19 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 56 | Esteky ( | 0.12 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 57 | Esteky ( | 0.25 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 58 | Esteky ( | 0.15 | 298 | TCE | ||||
| 59 | Esteky ( | 0.35 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 60 | Esteky ( | 0.36 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 61 | Esteky ( | 0.39 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 62 | Etale ( | 0.33 | 503 | ND | ||||
| 63 | Etale ( | 0.43 | 503 | FP | ||||
| 64 | Evans ( | 0.76 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 65 | Evans ( | 0.81 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 66 | Evans ( | 0.62 | 190 | SI | ||||
| 67 | Evans ( | 0.34 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 68 | Evans ( | 0.40 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 69 | Evans ( | 0.43 | 190 | SI | ||||
| 70 | Evans ( | 0.27 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 71 | Fischer & Hilboesen( | 0.08 | 449 | FP | ||||
| 72 | Fischer & Hilboesen( | 0.33 | 449 | FP | ||||
| 73 | Evans ( | 0.38 | 190 | FP | ||||
| 74 | Fatemi ( | 0.47 | 47 | Food | HDP | 50.00 | 24.00 | |
| 75 | Fatemi ( | 0.24 | 276 | Nfood | HDP | 60.00 | 35.00 | |
| 76 | He et al. ( | −0.23 | 202 | SI | ||||
| 77 | He et al. ( | 0.39 | 202 | Nfood | UTP | 46.00 | 35.86 | |
| 78 | Hooge ( | 0.05 | 1099 | Food | UTP | 45.00 | 41.63 | |
| 79 | Hu et al.( | 0.21 | 170 | SI | ||||
| 80 | Hu et al.( | 0.25 | 150 | SI | ||||
| 81 | Hu et al.( | 0.22 | 200 | SI | ||||
| 82 | Hu et al.( | 0.22 | 200 | Food | HDP | 64.50 | 31.30 | |
| 83 | Hu et al.( | 0.06 | 230 | SI | ||||
| 84 | Hu et al.( | 0.23 | 230 | SI | ||||
| 85 | Huang et al.( | 0.56 | 120 | Food | HDP | 50.80 | 30.54 | |
| 86 | Huang et al.( | 0.17 | 270 | Food | UTP | 46.70 | 36.49 | |
| 87 | Huang et al.( | 0.15 | 270 | Food | HDP | 46.70 | 36.49 | |
| 88 | Kumar ( | 0.27 | 501 | SI | ||||
| 89 | Kumar ( | 0.41 | 720 | TCE | ||||
| 90 | Lähteenmäki ( | 0.03 | 4612 | ND | ||||
| 91 | Lähteenmäki ( | 0.30 | 4612 | FP | ||||
| 92 | Lähteenmäki ( | 0.04 | 4612 | ND | ||||
| 93 | Li ( | 0.60 | 447 | Nfood | UTP | 50.14 | 32.20 | |
| 94 | Li ( | 0.61 | 499 | Nfood | UTP | 50.14 | 46.42 | |
| 95 | Li ( | 0.18 | 124 | Nfood | UTP | 48.40 | 22.70 | |
| 96 | Li ( | 0.18 | 230 | Nfood | UTP | 47.40 | 27.60 | |
| 97 | Li ( | 0.18 | 170 | Nfood | UTP | 51.80 | 28.20 | |
| 98 | Li ( | 0.69 | 113 | SI | ||||
| 99 | Li ( | 0.40 | 307 | SI | ||||
| 100 | Li ( | 0.46 | 113 | SI | ||||
| 101 | Li et al.( | 0.21 | 174 | SI | ||||
| 102 | Li et al.( | 0.00 | 188 | SI | ||||
| 103 | Li et al.( | 0.23 | 309 | SI | ||||
| 104 | Li et al.( | 0.06 | 309 | SI | ||||
| 105 | Lunardo ( | 0.15 | 156 | ND | ||||
| 106 | Lunardo ( | 0.18 | 156 | TCE | ||||
| 107 | Lunardo ( | 0.48 | 169 | TCE | ||||
| 108 | Lunardo ( | 0.45 | 169 | ND | ||||
| 109 | Ma et al.( | 0.51 | 177 | Nfood | UTP | 50.00 | 21.70 | |
| 110 | Ma et al.( | 0.37 | 413 | Nfood | UTP | 49.00 | 33.40 | |
| 111 | Ma et al.( | 0.32 | 1700 | Nfood | UTP | 52.37 | 32.93 | |
| 112 | Ma et al.( | 0.51 | 177 | Nfood | UTP | 50.00 | 21.70 | |
| 113 | Ma et al.( | 0.36 | 177 | SI | ||||
| 114 | Ma et al.( | 0.25 | 413 | SI | ||||
| 115 | Ma et al.( | 0.37 | 413 | Nfood | UTP | 50.00 | 21.70 | |
| 116 | Ma et al.( | 0.20 | 1700 | SI | ||||
| 117 | Marckhgott ( | 0.41 | 136 | SI | ||||
| 118 | Margariti ( | 0.33 | 305 | ND | ||||
| 119 | Margariti ( | 0.41 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 120 | Margariti ( | 0.50 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 121 | Margariti ( | 0.46 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 122 | Margariti ( | 0.45 | 305 | Food | HDP | 44.92 | 22.48 | |
| 123 | Marozzo ( | 0.23 | 101 | Food | UTP | 53.50 | 33.18 | |
| 124 | Marozzo ( | 0.18 | 101 | Food | UTP | 53.50 | 33.18 | |
| 125 | Marozzo ( | 0.23 | 104 | Food | HDP | 62.50 | 30.98 | |
| 126 | Marozzo ( | 0.18 | 104 | Food | HDP | 62.50 | 30.98 | |
| 127 | Marozzo ( | 0.21 | 198 | Food | UTP | 38.90 | 34.78 | |
| 128 | Marozzo ( | 0.25 | 198 | Food | UTP | 39.90 | 34.78 | |
| 129 | Marozzo ( | 0.04 | 198 | Food | HDP | 62.50 | 30.98 | |
| 130 | Marozzo ( | 0.33 | 212 | Food | UTP | 50.00 | 35.86 | |
| 131 | Marozzo ( | 0.30 | 212 | Food | UTP | 50.00 | 35.86 | |
| 132 | Meier et al.( | 0.30 | 118 | Nfood | HDP | 80.00 | 21.92 | |
| 133 | Nitzko ( | 0.39 | 222 | TCE | ||||
| 134 | Nitzko ( | 0.31 | 559 | FP | ||||
| 135 | Nitzko ( | 0.31 | 559 | FP | ||||
| 136 | Pichierri ( | 0.36 | 104 | SI | ||||
| 137 | Pichierri ( | 0.02 | 196 | SI | ||||
| 138 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.29 | 75 | ND | ||||
| 139 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.30 | 80 | ND | ||||
| 140 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.29 | 88 | ND | ||||
| 141 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.20 | 100 | ND | ||||
| 142 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.23 | 78 | ND | ||||
| 143 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.15 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 144 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.10 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 145 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.18 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 146 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.11 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 147 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.12 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 148 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.19 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 149 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.04 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 150 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.14 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 151 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.18 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 152 | Radaelli et al.( | 0.26 | 373 | ND | ||||
| 153 | Rozin ( | 0.66 | 97 | FP | ||||
| 154 | Rozin ( | 0.68 | 97 | FP | ||||
| 155 | Rozin ( | 0.56 | 99 | FP | ||||
| 156 | Rozin ( | 0.59 | 99 | FP | ||||
| 157 | Rozin ( | 0.13 | 99 | FP | ||||
| 158 | Saint-Eve et al.( | 0.96 | 64 | Food | HDP | 52.26 | 21.00 | |
| 159 | Scekic ( | 0.30 | 182 | FP | ||||
| 160 | Scekic ( | 0.06 | 285 | Nfood | UTP | 45.96 | 20.13 | |
| 161 | Scekic ( | 0.98 | 285 | FP | ||||
| 162 | Scekic ( | 0.57 | 285 | FP | ||||
| 163 | Scekic ( | 0.94 | 249 | FP | ||||
| 164 | Scott ( | 0.12 | 720 | TCE | ||||
| 165 | Siegrist ( | 0.64 | 588 | FP | ||||
| 166 | Siegrist ( | 0.67 | 183 | FP | ||||
| 167 | Siegrist ( | 0.19 | 244 | FP | ||||
| 168 | Siegrist ( | 0.22 | 244 | FP | ||||
| 169 | Siegrist ( | 0.69 | 253 | FP | ||||
| 170 | Siegrist ( | 0.55 | 253 | Food | UTP | 33.60 | 61.30 | |
| 171 | Staub ( | −0.09 | 486 | SI | ||||
| 172 | Staub ( | 0.14 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 173 | Staub ( | 0.13 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 174 | Staub ( | 0.12 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 175 | Staub ( | 0.09 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 176 | Staub ( | 0.59 | 486 | FP | ||||
| 177 | Steiner et al.(2026) | 0.29 | 559 | FP | ||||
| 178 | Steiner et al.(2026) | 0.13 | 261 | SI | ||||
| 179 | Stoltze ( | 0.09 | 497 | ND | ||||
| 180 | Stoltze ( | 0.35 | 497 | ND | ||||
| 181 | Stoltze ( | 0.09 | 497 | ND | ||||
| 182 | Szocs ( | 0.38 | 150 | SI | ||||
| 183 | Szocs ( | 0.00 | 100 | SI | ||||
| 184 | Szocs ( | 0.23 | 240 | SI | ||||
| 185 | Szocs ( | 0.19 | 300 | SI | ||||
| 186 | Szocs ( | 0.19 | 200 | SI | ||||
| 187 | Szocs ( | 0.22 | 300 | SI | ||||
| 188 | Szocs ( | 0.31 | 100 | SI | ||||
| 189 | Tenbült ( | −0.31 | 1400 | TCE | ||||
| 190 | Tsai et al.( | 0.22 | 100 | Nfood | HDP | 54.00 | 38.78 | |
| 191 | Wang (2022) | 0.27 | 138 | Food | UTP | 57.20 | 29.91 | |
| 192 | Wang (2022) | 0.53 | 137 | Food | UTP | 52.60 | 29.52 | |
| 193 | Wang (2022) | 0.38 | 113 | Food | UTP | 66.40 | 28.01 | |
| 194 | Wang ( | 0.43 | 162 | SI | ||||
| 195 | Wang ( | 0.37 | 162 | SI | ||||
| 196 | Wang ( | 0.26 | 165 | SI | ||||
| 197 | Wang et al.( | 0.35 | 407 | Food | HDP | 48.65 | 33.20 | |
| 198 | Xu ( | 0.42 | 200 | Food | HDP | 61.50 | 31.80 | |
| 199 | Yang ( | 0.26 | 216 | Food | UTP | 65.20 | 32.20 | |
| 200 | Yang ( | 0.22 | 216 | Food | UTP | 65.20 | 32.20 | |
| 201 | Yang ( | 0.42 | 227 | TCE | ||||
| 202 | Zhang ( | 0.17 | 142 | SI | ||||
| 203 | Zhang ( | 0.03 | 153 | SI | ||||
| 204 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.20 | 170 | ND | ||||
| 205 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.57 | 170 | Food | UTP | 74.70 | 32.08 | |
| 206 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.38 | 170 | Food | UTP | 74.70 | 32.08 | |
| 207 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.07 | 260 | ND | ||||
| 208 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.30 | 260 | ND | ||||
| 209 | Zhang et al.(2026) | 0.19 | 260 | Food | UTP | 64.60 | 31.93 | |
| 210 | Zhu & Jin (2025) | 0.40 | 149 | SI | ||||
| 211 | 陈婷婷 (2021) | −0.42 | 216 | Food | HDP | 57.90 | 25.10 | |
| 212 | 陈婷婷 (2021) | −0.32 | 216 | Food | HDP | 57.90 | 25.10 | |
| 213 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.33 | 72 | Nfood | HDP | 45.80 | 24.60 | |
| 214 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.34 | 86 | Food | UTP | 53.50 | 24.80 | |
| 215 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.28 | 88 | Food | UTP | 68.20 | 24.20 | |
| 216 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.44 | 184 | Nfood | UTP | 64.70 | 25.70 | |
| 217 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.48 | 208 | Nfood | UTP | 100.00 | 25.90 | |
| 218 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.41 | 264 | Food | HDP | 60.20 | 24.20 | |
| 219 | 陈婷婷 (2024) | −0.14 | 206 | Nfood | HDP | 61.70 | 24.20 | |
| 220 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.21 | 198 | TCE | ||||
| 221 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.19 | 238 | TCE | ||||
| 222 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.73 | 249 | TCE | ||||
| 223 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.21 | 421 | TCE | ||||
| 224 | 苏璟赟 ( | 0.17 | 228 | TCE | ||||
| 225 | 朱培 ( | −0.21 | 120 | Nfood | UTP | 62.50 | 28.80 | |
| 226 | 朱培 ( | −0.22 | 170 | Food | HDP | 65.90 | 28.54 | |
| 227 | 朱培 ( | −0.16 | 160 | Nfood | HDP | 74.40 | 30.20 | |
| 228 | 朱培 ( | −0.15 | 270 | Food | HDP | 68.90 | 30.20 | |
| 229 | 朱培 ( | 0.37 | 100 | Nfood | HDP | 66.00 | 25.60 |
| (*为纳入元分析文章) | |
| [1] | * 陈婷婷. (2020). 品牌标识低自然性与品牌个性匹配对品牌资产的影响 [博士学位论文]. 武汉大学. |
| [2] |
刘红艳, 周泳含, 陈艳霞. (2024). 次优食品营销干预策略的有效性探究: 来自元分析的证据. 心理科学进展, 32(10), 1640-1662.
doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1042.2024.01640 |
| [3] |
柳武妹, 马增光, 卫旭华. (2020). 拥挤影响消费者情绪和购物反应的元分析. 心理学报, 52(10), 1237-1254.
doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1041.2020.01237 |
| [4] | QYResearch. (2025-04-15). 全球与中国天然食品市场现状及未来发展趋势. 取自 https://www.qyresearch.com.cn/reports/5609324/natural-food |
| [5] | * 苏璟赟. (2023). 社会拥挤对消费者自然产品偏好的影响研究 [博士学位论文]. 湖南大学. |
| [6] | 孙瑾, 刘瑞凝. (2025). 返璞归心:扎根感对消费者自然产品偏好的影响研究. 国际商务(对外经济贸易大学学报), (1), 137-156.https://doi.org/10.13509/j.cnki.ib.2025.01.007. |
| [7] |
卫旭华. (2016). 薪酬水平和薪酬差距对企业运营结果影响的元分析. 心理科学进展, 24(7), 1020-1031.
doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1042.2016.01020 |
| [8] | 卫旭华, 王傲晨, 江楠. (2018). 团队断层前因及其对团队过程与结果影响的元分析. 南开管理评论, 21(5), 139-149+187. |
| [9] | * 朱培. (2023). 自然广告诉求对消费者购买意愿的影响研究 [博士学位论文]. 湖南大学. |
| [10] |
* Abouab, N., & Gomez, P. (2015). Human contact imagined during the production process increases food naturalness perceptions. Appetite, 91, 273-277.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2015.04.002 pmid: 25862979 |
| [11] |
Ahluwalia, R., & Gürhan-Canli, Z. (2000). The effects of extensions on the family brand name: An accessibility- diagnosticity perspective. Journal of Consumer Research, 27(3), 371-381.
doi: 10.1086/317591 URL |
| [12] |
Aksoy, N. C., Kabadayi, E. T., & Alan, A. K. (2021). An unintended consequence of Covid-19: Healthy nutrition. Appetite, 166, 105430.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2021.105430 URL |
| [13] |
* Amos, C., Hansen, J. C., & King, S. (2019). All-natural versus organic: Are the labels equivalent in consumers’ minds? Journal of Consumer Marketing, 36(4), 516-526.
doi: 10.1108/JCM-05-2018-2664 URL |
| [14] | * Amos, C., Pentina, I., Hawkins, T. G., & Davis, N. (2014). “Natural” labeling and consumers’ sentimental pastoral notion. Journal of Product & Brand Management, 23(4/5), 268-281. |
| [15] |
Anisimova, T., & Vrontis, D. (2024). The food you can trust: The moderating role of age in the relationship between consumer values and organic food trust. Journal of Business Research, 182, 114803.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2024.114803 URL |
| [16] | Apte, J. S., Brauer, M., Cohen, A. J., Ezzati, M., & Pope III, C. A. (2018). Ambient PM2. 5 reduces global and regional life expectancy. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 5(9), 546-551. |
| [17] |
Batra, R., & Ahtola, O. T. (1991). Measuring the hedonic and utilitarian sources of consumer attitudes. Marketing Letters, 2(2), 159-170.
doi: 10.1007/BF00436035 URL |
| [18] | Battacchi, D., Verkerk, R., Pellegrini, N., Fogliano, V., & Steenbekkers, B. (2020). The state of the art of food ingredients’ naturalness evaluation: A review of proposed approaches and their relation with consumer trends. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 106, 434-444. |
| [19] |
Bearth, A., Cousin, M. E., & Siegrist, M. (2014). The consumer’s perception of artificial food additives: Influences on acceptance, risk and benefit perceptions. Food Quality and Preference, 38, 14-23.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2014.05.008 URL |
| [20] |
Belk, R. W. (1975). Situational variables and consumer behavior. Journal of Consumer Research, 2(3), 157-164.
doi: 10.1086/jcr.1975.2.issue-3 URL |
| [21] |
* Berry, C., Burton, S., & Howlett, E. (2017). It’s only natural: The mediating impact of consumers’ attribute inferences on the relationships between product claims, perceived product healthfulness, and purchase intentions. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 45(5), 698-719.
doi: 10.1007/s11747-016-0511-8 URL |
| [22] |
Besthorn, F. H., & Saleebey, D. (2003). Nature, genetics and the biophilia connection: Exploring linkages with social work values and practice. Advances in Social Work, 4(1), 1-18.
doi: 10.18060/39 URL |
| [23] |
Beugelsdijk, S., & Welzel, C. (2018). Dimensions and dynamics of national culture: Synthesizing Hofstede with Inglehart. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 49(10), 1469-1505.
doi: 10.1177/0022022118798505 pmid: 30369633 |
| [24] | Borenstein, M., Hedges, L. V., Higgins, J. P., & Rothstein, H. R. (2021). Introduction to meta-analysis. John Wiley & Sons. |
| [25] |
Brough, A. R., Wilkie, J. E., Ma, J., Isaac, M. S., & Gal, D. (2016). Is eco-friendly unmanly? The green-feminine stereotype and its effect on sustainable consumption. Journal of Consumer Research, 43(4), 567-582.
doi: 10.1093/jcr/ucw044 URL |
| [26] |
Campbell, M. C., Inman, J., J., Kirmani, A., & Price, L. L. (2020). In times of trouble: A framework for understanding consumers’ responses to threats. Journal of Consumer Research, 47(3), 311-326.
doi: 10.1093/jcr/ucaa036 URL |
| [27] |
Chaiken, S. (1980). Heuristic versus systematic information processing and the use of source versus message cues in persuasion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(5), 752-766.
doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.39.5.752 URL |
| [28] | * Chen, S., Yu, Z., Xiong, J., & Ponomarenko, V. (2025). Navigating ethical paths with “less”: Unveiling the simplicity-naturalness association and its impact on green consumption. Journal of Business Ethics, 1-20. |
| [29] | * Chen, T. (2022). Consumers’ inferences of product naturalness and healthiness: The role of ingredient quantity and labeling [Unpublished doctorial dissertation]. Boston University. |
| [30] |
* Chen, T., Wu, Z., Hu, L., & Jia, Q. (2023). The visual naturalness effect: Impact of natural logos on brand personality perception. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 47(4), 1351-1363.
doi: 10.1111/ijcs.v47.4 URL |
| [31] |
* Cheng, Y., & Mukhopadhyay, A. (2024). An aversion to intervention: How the protestant work ethic influences preferences for natural healthcare. Journal of Consumer Research, 51(4), 679-697.
doi: 10.1093/jcr/ucae033 URL |
| [32] |
Chitturi, R., Raghunathan, R., & Mahajan, V. (2008). Delight by design: The role of hedonic versus utilitarian benefits. Journal of Marketing, 72(3), 48-63.
doi: 10.1509/JMKG.72.3.048 URL |
| [33] | Choi, J., Chambers IV, E., & Lee, J. (2025). Consumer sensory perceptions of natural ingredients: A multi-country comparison. Foods, 14(10), 1775. |
| [34] | Cohen, A. J., Brauer, M., Burnett, R., Anderson, H. R., Frostad, J., Estep, K.,... Forouzanfar, M. H. (2017). Estimates and 25-year trends of the global burden of disease attributable to ambient air pollution: An analysis of data from the Global Burden of Diseases Study 2015. The Lancet, 389(10082), 1907-1918. |
| [35] | * D’Astous, A., & Labrecque, J. (2021). The impact of responsible food packaging perceptions on naturalness and healthiness inferences, and consumer buying intentions. Foods, 10(10), 2366. |
| [36] |
* De Hooge, I. E. (2025). Increasing the purchase intentions for suboptimal products: Comparing potential marketing strategies. Food Quality and Preference, 123, 105314.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2024.105314 URL |
| [37] |
Devia, G., Forli, S., Vidal, L., Curutchet, M. R., & Ares, G. (2021). References to home-made and natural foods on the labels of ultra-processed products increase healthfulness perception and purchase intention: Insights for policy making. Food Quality and Preference, 88, 104110.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2020.104110 URL |
| [38] |
Dhar, R., & Wertenbroch, K. (2000). Consumer choice between hedonic and utilitarian goods. Journal of Marketing Research, 37(1), 60-71.
doi: 10.1509/jmkr.37.1.60.18718 URL |
| [39] |
Dickson-Spillmann, M., Siegrist, M., & Keller, C. (2011). Attitudes toward chemicals are associated with preference for natural food. Food Quality and Preference, 22(1), 149-156.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2010.09.001 URL |
| [40] |
Dodell-Feder, D., & Tamir, D. I. (2018). Fiction reading has a small positive impact on social cognition: A meta- analysis. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 147(11), 1713-1727.
doi: 10.1037/xge0000395 URL |
| [41] |
* Du, Y., & Wang, X. (2024). Is there also a hidden health cue in the background? The impact of natural imagery on product attitude in food marketing. Food Quality and Preference, 120, 105256.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2024.105256 URL |
| [42] |
Eisend, M., & Stokburger-Sauer, N. E. (2013). Brand personality: A meta-analytic review of antecedents and consequences. Marketing Letters, 24(3), 205-216.
doi: 10.1007/s11002-013-9232-7 URL |
| [43] |
Eisend, M., & Tarrahi, F. (2022). Persuasion knowledge in the marketplace: A meta‐analysis. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 32(1), 3-22.
doi: 10.1002/jcpy.v32.1 URL |
| [44] | * Ercan, S., Yaprak, B., Ecevit, M. Z., & Duman, O. (2025). Sustainable but disgusting? A psychological model of consumer reactions to human-hair-derived textiles. Sustainability, 17(17), 7799. |
| [45] |
* Esteky, S. (2021). Chirping birds and barking dogs: The interactive effect of ambient sensory cue source and valence on consumers’ choice of natural products. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 61, 102513.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2021.102513 URL |
| [46] |
* Etale, A., & Siegrist, M. (2021). Food processing and perceived naturalness: Is it more natural or just more traditional?. Food Quality and Preference, 94, 104323.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2021.104323 URL |
| [47] |
* Evans, G., de Challemaison, B., & Cox, D. N. (2010). Consumers’ ratings of the natural and unnatural qualities of foods. Appetite, 54(3), 557-563.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2010.02.014 pmid: 20197074 |
| [48] | Fairfield Market Research. (2024, May 21). Natural health supplements market: Global industry analysis, size, share, growth, trends, and forecast 2031. ArsTechnica. https://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/5943031/natural-health-supplements-market-global#src-pos-4 |
| [49] | Fakhreddine, L. B., Martínez, M. G., Sánchez, M., & Schnettler, B. (2023). Consumers’ willingness to pay for health claims during the COVID-19 pandemic: A moderated mediation analysis. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research, 11(4), 100523. |
| [50] |
Fan, X., Deng, N., Qian, Y., & Dong, X. (2022). Factors affecting the effectiveness of cause-related marketing: A meta-analysis. Journal of Business Ethics, 175(2), 339-360.
doi: 10.1007/s10551-020-04639-6 |
| [51] |
* Fatemi, H., & Wan, J. (2024). A natural fit: Exposure to nature influences regulatory focus. European Journal of Marketing, 58(8), 1888-1909.
doi: 10.1108/EJM-01-2022-0054 URL |
| [52] |
Feldman, J. M., & Lynch, J. G. (1988). Self-generated validity and other effects of measurement on belief, attitude, intention, and behavior. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73(3), 421-435.
doi: 10.1037/0021-9010.73.3.421 URL |
| [53] |
* Fischer, A. R., & Hilboesen, O. (2025). Consumer acceptance of mycelium as protein source. Food Quality and Preference, 122, 105304.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2024.105304 URL |
| [54] |
Galoni, C., Carpenter, G. S., & Rao, H. (2020). Disgusted and afraid: Consumer choices under the threat of contagious disease. Journal of Consumer Research, 47(3), 373-392.
doi: 10.1093/jcr/ucaa025 URL |
| [55] |
Grewal, D., Levy, M., & Kumar, V. (2009). Customer experience management in retailing: An organizing framework. Journal of Retailing, 85(1), 1-14.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretai.2009.01.001 URL |
| [56] |
Grunert, K. G., Fernández-Celemín, L., Wills, J. M., Storcksdieck genannt Bonsmann, S., & Nureeva, L. (2010). Use and understanding of nutrition information on food labels in six European countries. Journal of Public Health, 18(3), 261-277.
doi: 10.1007/s10389-009-0307-0 URL |
| [57] |
* He, L., Lin, M., Liang, S., Geng, L., & Chen, Z. (2024). Which aesthetics works, classical or expressive? How and when aesthetic appearance enhances green consumption. Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, 36(10), 2483-2501.
doi: 10.1108/APJML-12-2023-1214 URL |
| [58] |
* Hu, L., Wang, S., Zheng, J., & Xu, Q. (2025). How to present food images on packaging? The influence of aesthetics design on consumers' perceived healthiness. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 85, 104264.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2025.104264 URL |
| [59] |
* Huang, M., Xiao, Q., Zhou, X., & Yu, Y. (2026). How numerical latitude origin expressions increase consumers' purchase intention: The role of perceived naturalness. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 25(3), 1432-1459.
doi: 10.1002/cb.v25.3 URL |
| [60] |
Joshi, A., & Roh, H. (2009). The role of context in work team diversity research: A meta-analytic review. Academy of Management Journal, 52(3), 599-627.
doi: 10.5465/amj.2009.41331491 URL |
| [61] |
Kadic-Maglajlic, S., Arslanagic-Kalajdzic, M., Micevski, M., Dlacic, J., & Zabkar, V. (2019). Being engaged is a good thing: Understanding sustainable consumption behavior among young adults. Journal of Business Research, 104, 644-654.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2019.02.040 |
| [62] |
Kahneman, D. (2003). Maps of bounded rationality: Psychology for behavioral economics. American Economic Review, 93(5), 1449-1475.
doi: 10.1257/000282803322655392 URL |
| [63] |
* Kumar, S., Dhir, A., Talwar, S., Chakraborty, D., & Kaur, P. (2021). What drives brand love for natural products? The moderating role of household size. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 58, 102329.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2020.102329 URL |
| [64] |
Kushwah, S., Dhir, A., & Sagar, M. (2019). Understanding consumer resistance to the consumption of organic food. A study of ethical consumption, purchasing, and choice behaviour. Food Quality and Preference, 77, 1-14.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2019.04.003 URL |
| [65] |
* Lähteenmäki, L., Lampila, P., Grunert, K., Boztug, Y., Ueland, Ø., Åström, A., & Martinsdóttir, E. (2010). Impact of health-related claims on the perception of other product attributes. Food Policy, 35(3), 230-239.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodpol.2009.12.007 URL |
| [66] |
Lang, M., & Rodrigues, A. C. (2022). A comparison of organic-certified versus non-certified natural foods: Perceptions and motives and their influence on purchase behaviors. Appetite, 168, 105698.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2021.105698 URL |
| [67] |
Lee, D. C., & Kim, J. (2024). Feeling younger and acting greener: The impact of subjective age on sustainable consumption. Psychology & Marketing, 41(10), 2310-2328.
doi: 10.1002/mar.v41.10 URL |
| [68] |
Lee, J. A., Garbarino, E., & Lerman, D. (2007). How cultural differences in uncertainty avoidance affect product perceptions. International Marketing Review, 24(3), 330-349.
doi: 10.1108/02651330710755320 URL |
| [69] | Lee, W. C. J., Shimizu, M., Kniffin, K. M., & Wansink, B. (2013). You taste what you see: Do organic labels bias taste perceptions?. Food Quality and Preference, 29(1), 33-39. |
| [70] |
Leonidou, L. C., Eteokleous, P. P., Christofi, A. M., & Korfiatis, N. (2022). Drivers, outcomes, and moderators of consumer intention to buy organic goods: Meta-analysis, implications, and future agenda. Journal of Business Research, 151, 339-354.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2022.06.027 URL |
| [71] |
* Li, G., Li, X., & Wang, X. (2025). Visually rough appears healthier: The effect of visual roughness in package design on consumers' food and beverage purchase intention. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 25(2), 727-743.
doi: 10.1002/cb.v25.2 URL |
| [72] |
* Li, H., & Cao, Y. (2020). For the love of nature: People who prefer natural versus synthetic drugs are higher in nature connectedness. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 71, 101496.
doi: 10.1016/j.jenvp.2020.101496 URL |
| [73] |
* Li, M., & Chapman, G. B. (2012). Why do people like natural? Instrumental and ideational bases for the naturalness preference. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 42(12), 2859-2878.
doi: 10.1111/jasp.2012.42.issue-12 URL |
| [74] | * Li, S., Liang, J., Zhou, S., & Kang, Q. (2022). The symmetry effect: Symmetrical shapes increase consumer’s health perception of food. Journal of Food Quality, 2022(1), 5202087. |
| [75] | Lipsey, M. W., & Wilson, D. B. (2001). The way in which intervention studies have “personality” and why it is important to meta-analysis. Evaluation & the Health Professions, 24(3), 236-254. |
| [76] |
* Lunardo, R., & Saintives, C. (2013). The effect of naturalness claims on perceptions of food product naturalness in the point of purchase. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 20(6), 529-537.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2013.05.006 URL |
| [77] | * Ma, Y., Mohaidin, Z., Isa, S. M., Gu, R., & Sun, Z. (2025). From aesthetics to action: How classical and expressive design cues shape consumers’ green purchasing intentions. Journal of Marketing Analytics, https://doi.org/10.1057/s41270-025-00434-2 |
| [78] |
* Marckhgott, E., & Kamleitner, B. (2019). Matte matters: When matte packaging increases perceptions of food naturalness. Marketing Letters, 30, 167-178.
doi: 10.1007/s11002-019-09488-6 |
| [79] | * Margariti, K. (2021). “White” space and organic claims on food packaging: Communicating sustainability values and affecting young adults’ attitudes and purchase intentions. Sustainability, 13(19), 11101. |
| [80] |
* Marozzo, V., Raimondo, M. A., Miceli, G. N., & Scopelliti, I. (2020). Effects of au naturel packaging colors on willingness to pay for healthy food. Psychology & Marketing, 37(7), 913-927.
doi: 10.1002/mar.v37.7 URL |
| [81] | Meier, B. P., Dillard, A. J., & Lappas, C. M. (2019). Naturally better? A review of the natural‐is‐better bias. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 13(8), e12494. |
| [82] |
* Meier, B. P., Noreen, E. E., Ji, L. J., Fellman, M. B., & Lappas, C. M. (2025). Perceived naturalness biases objective behavior in both trivial and meaningful contexts. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 16(1), 105-112.
doi: 10.1177/19485506241276027 URL |
| [83] |
Mizerski, R. W., Golden, L. L., & Kernan, J. B. (1979). The attribution process in consumer decision making. Journal of Consumer Research, 6(2), 123-140.
doi: 10.1086/jcr.1979.6.issue-2 URL |
| [84] |
Molinillo, S., Vidal-Branco, M., & Japutra, A. (2020). Understanding the drivers of organic foods purchasing of millennials: Evidence from Brazil and Spain. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 52, 101926.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2019.101926 URL |
| [85] |
Money, R. B., & Crotts, J. C. (2003). The effect of uncertainty avoidance on information search, planning, and purchases of international travel vacations. Tourism Management, 24(2), 191-202.
doi: 10.1016/S0261-5177(02)00057-2 URL |
| [86] | Murley, T., & Chambers IV, E. (2019). The influence of colorants, flavorants and product identity on perceptions of naturalness. Foods, 8(8), 317. |
| [87] |
Nardi, V. A. M., Jardim, W. C., Ladeira, W. J., & Santini, F. (2020). A meta-analysis of the relationship between customer participation and brand outcomes. Journal of Business Research, 117, 450-460.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2020.06.017 URL |
| [88] |
Neumann, N., Böckenholt, U., & Sinha, A. (2016). A meta- analysis of extremeness aversion. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 26(2), 193-212.
doi: 10.1016/j.jcps.2015.05.005 URL |
| [89] |
Nguyen, N., Priporas, C. V., McPherson, M., & Manyiwa, S. (2023). CSR-related consumer scepticism: A review of the literature and future research directions. Journal of Business Research, 169, 114294.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2023.114294 URL |
| [90] | * Nitzko, S. (2024). Consumer evaluation of food from pesticide-free agriculture in relation to conventional and organic products. Farming System, 2(4), 100112. |
| [91] |
Nolte, J., & Hanoch, Y. (2024). Adult age differences in risk perception and risk taking. Current Opinion in Psychology, 55, 101746.
doi: 10.1016/j.copsyc.2023.101746 URL |
| [92] |
Pan, M., Blut, M., Ghiassaleh, A., & Lee, Z. W. (2025). Influencer marketing effectiveness: A meta-analytic review. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 53(1), 52-78.
doi: 10.1007/s11747-024-01052-7 |
| [93] | Petty, R. E., & Cacioppo, J. T. (1986). The elaboration likelihood model of persuasion. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (19, pp. 123-205). Academic Press. |
| [94] |
* Pichierri, M., & Pino, G. (2023). Less saturated, more eco- friendly: Color saturation and consumer perception of product sustainability. Psychology & Marketing, 40(9), 1830-1849.
doi: 10.1002/mar.v40.9 URL |
| [95] |
Purohit, D., & Srivastava, J. (2001). Effect of manufacturer reputation, retailer reputation, and product warranty on consumer judgments of product quality: A cue diagnosticity framework. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 10(3), 123-134.
doi: 10.1207/s15327663jcp1003_1 URL |
| [96] | * Radaelli, D., Hässig-Wegmann, A., Román, S., Sanchez- Siles, L., & Siegrist, M. (2025). The misuse of “natural” claims on food products and how they can influence perceptions of naturalness and healthiness. Food Research International, 220, 117094. |
| [97] |
Raghunathan, R., Naylor, R. W., & Hoyer, W. D. (2006). The unhealthy= tasty intuition and its effects on taste inferences, enjoyment, and choice of food products. Journal of Marketing, 70(4), 170-184.
doi: 10.1509/jmkg.70.4.170 URL |
| [98] |
Rockstuhl, T., Dulebohn, J. H., Ang, S., & Shore, L. M. (2012). Leader-member exchange (LMX) and culture: A meta-analysis of correlates of LMX across 23 countries. Journal of Applied Psychology, 97(6), 1097-1130.
doi: 10.1037/a0029978 pmid: 22985117 |
| [99] | Roman, S., Sánchez-Siles, L. M., & Siegrist, M. (2017). The importance of food naturalness for consumers: Results of a systematic review. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 67, 44-57. |
| [100] |
* Rozin, P. (2006). Naturalness judgments by lay Americans: Process dominates content in judgments of food or water acceptability and naturalness. Judgment and Decision Making, 1(2), 91-97.
doi: 10.1017/S1930297500002308 URL |
| [101] | Rozin, P., Chen, R., Scott, S. E., & Cusimano, C. (2024). Americans believe in the benevolence of nature, and this belief is not lower in people who have experienced natural disasters. Judgment and Decision Making, 19, e18. |
| [102] |
Rozin, P., Fischler, C., & Shields-Argelès, C. (2009). Additivity dominance: Additivites are more potent and more often lexicalized across languages than are “subtractives”. Judgment and Decision Making, 4(6), 475-478.
doi: 10.1017/S1930297500004010 URL |
| [103] |
Rozin, P., Fischler, C., & Shields-Argelès, C. (2012). European and American perspectives on the meaning of natural. Appetite, 59(2), 448-455.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2012.06.001 pmid: 22698976 |
| [104] |
Rozin, P., Spranca, M., Krieger, Z., Neuhaus, R., Surillo, D., Swerdlin, A., & Wood, K. (2004). Preference for natural: Instrumental and ideational/moral motivations, and the contrast between foods and medicines. Appetite, 43(2), 147-154.
pmid: 15458801 |
| [105] |
Rybak, G., Burton, S., Johnson, A. M., & Berry, C. (2021). Promoted claims on food product packaging: Comparing direct and indirect effects of processing and nutrient content claims. Journal of Business Research, 135, 464-479.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.06.036 URL |
| [106] |
* Saint-Eve, A., Souchon, I., Soler, L. G., & Delarue, J. (2025). Liking and sensory determinants of perceived naturalness and healthiness. A study on pizzas with young adults in a natural eating environment. Food Quality and Preference, 123, 105330.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2024.105330 URL |
| [107] |
* Saintives, C., & Meral, H. (2024). Is it really natural? How minimalist food packaging influences consumers’ perception of product naturalness. British Food Journal, 126(11), 3888-3905.
doi: 10.1108/BFJ-03-2024-0299 URL |
| [108] | Sanchez-Siles, L. M., Michel, F., Román, S., Bernal, M. J., Philipsen, B., Haro, J. F.,... Siegrist, M. (2019). The Food Naturalness Index (FNI): An integrative tool to measure the degree of food naturalness. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 91, 681-690. |
| [109] |
* Scekic, A., & Krishna, A. (2021). Do firm cues impact product perceptions? When small is natural. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 31(2), 350-359.
doi: 10.1002/jcpy.v31.2 URL |
| [110] | Schirmacher, H., & Boztug, Y. (2026). That’s too close! The role of product-body proximity in naturalness marketing. European Journal of Marketing, 60(13), 353-390. |
| [111] |
Schirmacher, H., Elshiewy, O., & Boztug, Y. (2023). That's not natural! Consumer response to disconfirmed expectations about ‘natural’ food. Appetite, 180, 106270.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2022.106270 URL |
| [112] |
* Scott, S. E., Rozin, P., & Small, D. A. (2020). Consumers prefer “natural” more for preventatives than for curatives. Journal of Consumer Research, 47(3), 454-471.
doi: 10.1093/jcr/ucaa034 URL |
| [113] |
Siegrist, M., & Hartmann, C. (2020). Consumer acceptance of novel food technologies. Nature Food, 1(6), 343-350.
doi: 10.1038/s43016-020-0094-x pmid: 37128090 |
| [114] |
* Siegrist, M., & Sütterlin, B. (2017). Importance of perceived naturalness for acceptance of food additives and cultured meat. Appetite, 113, 320-326.
doi: S0195-6663(17)30392-6 pmid: 28315418 |
| [115] |
* Siegrist, M., Hartmann, C., & Sütterlin, B. (2016). Biased perception about gene technology: How perceived naturalness and affect distort benefit perception. Appetite, 96, 509-516.
doi: S0195-6663(15)30072-6 pmid: 26505287 |
| [116] |
Söderlund, M., & Mattsson, J. (2020). Consumers’ reactions to unsubstantiated claims about ecological products. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 37(5), 569-578.
doi: 10.1108/JCM-08-2019-3364 URL |
| [117] |
* Staub, C., Michel, F., Bucher, T., & Siegrist, M. (2020). How do you perceive this wine? Comparing naturalness perceptions of Swiss and Australian consumers. Food Quality and Preference, 79, 103752.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2019.103752 URL |
| [118] |
Steenkamp, J. B. E., Ter Hofstede, F., & Wedel, M. (1999). A cross-national investigation into the individual and national cultural antecedents of consumer innovativeness. Journal of Marketing, 63(2), 55-69.
doi: 10.1177/002224299906300204 URL |
| [119] | * Steiner, K., Kunz, S., & Florack, A. (2025). Less is more: How package color saturation influences naturalness perceptions of plant-based meat alternatives. Food Quality and Preference, 136, 105735. doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2025.105735 |
| [120] |
* Stoltze, F. M., Busey, E., Taillie, L. S., & Carpentier, F. R. D. (2021). Impact of warning labels on reducing health halo effects of nutrient content claims on breakfast cereal packages: A mixed-measures experiment. Appetite, 163, 105229.
doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2021.105229 URL |
| [121] | Szakos, D., Ozsvari, L., & Kasza, G. (2020). Perception of older adults about health-related functionality of foods compared with other age groups. Sustainability, 12(7), 2748. |
| [122] |
* Szocs, C., Williamson, S., & Mills, A. (2022). Contained: Why it’s better to display some products without a package. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 50(1), 131-146.
doi: 10.1007/s11747-021-00800-3 |
| [123] |
Taghikhah, F., Voinov, A., Shukla, N., & Filatova, T. (2021). Shifts in consumer behavior towards organic products: Theory-driven data analytics. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 61, 102516.
doi: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2021.102516 URL |
| [124] |
* Tenbült, P., de Vries, N. K., Dreezens, E., & Martijn, C. (2005). Perceived naturalness and acceptance of genetically modified food. Appetite, 45(1), 47-50.
pmid: 15896875 |
| [125] | * Tsai, H. T. (2025). The effects of naturalness in green advertising: How attention restoration, attention concentration and perceived psychological well‐being enhance consumers' product perceptions and purchase intentions. Journal of Sensory Studies, 40(2), e70038. |
| [126] |
Van der Vossen-Wijmenga, W. P., Zwietering, M. H., Boer, E. P., Velema, E., & den Besten, H. M. (2022). Perception of food-related risks: Difference between consumers and experts and changes over time. Food Control, 141, 109142.
doi: 10.1016/j.foodcont.2022.109142 URL |
| [127] |
Voss, K. E., Spangenberg, E. R., & Grohmann, B. (2003). Measuring the hedonic and utilitarian dimensions of consumer attitude. Journal of Marketing Research, 40(3), 310-320.
doi: 10.1509/jmkr.40.3.310.19238 URL |
| [128] |
* Wang, H., Li, H., Zhao, Y., & Xi, N. (2023). Being natural is aesthetic: The effects of “natural” labeling on lay beliefs and the purchase intention of unattractive produce. Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, 35(7), 1759-1773.
doi: 10.1108/APJML-04-2022-0316 URL |
| [129] | * Wang, W., Chen, Z., & Kuang, J. (2025). Artificial intelligence-driven recommendations and functional food purchases: Understanding consumer decision-making. Foods, 14(6), 976. |
| [130] |
* Wang, X., Chen, J., Ma, C., & Jiang, Y. (2024). Simpler is greener: The impact of packaging visual complexity on products' eco‐friendliness perception. Psychology & Marketing, 41(12), 2992-3008.
doi: 10.1002/mar.v41.12 URL |
| [131] |
Wardle, J., Haase, A. M., Steptoe, A., Nillapun, M., Jonwutiwes, K., & Bellisie, F. (2004). Gender differences in food choice: The contribution of health beliefs and dieting. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 27(2), 107-116.
doi: 10.1207/s15324796abm2702_5 pmid: 15053018 |
| [132] |
Xu, S., & Ding, Y. (2026). Feelings over reasons: The impact of exposure to nature on consumer decision making. Journal of Business Research, 207, 116011.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2026.116011 URL |
| [133] |
* Xu, Z. (2026). The interaction effect of packaging color and cognitive style on consumer purchase intention. British Food Journal, 128(1), 171-190.
doi: 10.1108/BFJ URL |
| [134] |
* Yang, X., Huang, Y., & Chen, Q. (2023). Less delicious but more natural: The effect of the natural label in promoting ugly food consumption. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 115, 103601.
doi: 10.1016/j.ijhm.2023.103601 URL |
| [135] |
Yen, D., Cohen, G., Wei, L., & Asaad, Y. (2022). Towards a framework of healthy aging practices. Journal of Business Research, 142, 176-187.
doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.12.026 URL |
| [136] | * Zhang, J., Wu, Z., Hu, Y., Li, Y., Wang, J., & Hu, J. (2025). Ugly outside, healthy inside: How packaging information labels shape consumer perceptions of imperfect fruits. Food Quality and Preference, 138, 105832. doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2025.105832 |
| [137] | * Zhang, K., Hou, Y., & Li, G. (2024). Color and naturalness: How color saturation shapes tourists' perception and purchase intention. International Journal of Tourism Research, 26(4), e2717. |
| [138] |
* Zhu, Y., & Jin, X. (2023). Is food produced by farmers healthier, more natural, and gaining more popularity? Research on the influencing mechanism of food producer labels on consumers’ food choices. Frontiers in Public Health, 11, 1255023.
doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1255023 URL |
| [1] | WANG Dan, CHEN Wenfeng, WANG Hui, FU Yujia, LIU Junye, LIU Zhengkui. The shared neural mechanisms of emotional contagion and bodily self-representation [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(8): 1351-1370. |
| [2] | SONG Haojie, YIN Qian, ZHANG Qiang, YANG Yansui. Longitudinal changes and social causes of older adults’ ageing attitudes in China [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(8): 1371-1385. |
| [3] | ZHANG Xiaoyan, SU Fangguo. The influence of socially responsible human resource management on employee work outcomes: A meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(8): 1386-1409. |
| [4] | XU Jie, HUANG Yinghang, GAI Xiaosong. The relationship between family factors and children’s executive function: A series of meta-analyses [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(7): 1170-1188. |
| [5] | HUANG Chuanbin, WANG Yang, DING Yi, GUO Yongyu. The effects of belief in a just world on third-party punishment: A three-level meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(6): 992-1009. |
| [6] | REN Weicong, FAN Junlong, ZHANG Zhijie. Dual characteristics of attentional bias in depression: A three-level meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(4): 666-686. |
| [7] | LYU Yanqi, WEI Qingwang. Holding balance brings harmony: A three-level meta-analysis of the relationship between Zhongyong thinking and mental health [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(4): 687-709. |
| [8] | WU Jing-Ying, JIA Ting-Rui, WANG Ya-Meng, LV Sa-Sa, WANG Zuo-Jun, WANG Li-Jun, CHAN Kai Qin. The association between socioeconomic status and belief in a just world: A three-level meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(12): 2274-2294. |
| [9] | WAN Qianyi, WEN Siqing, MA Zaoming, HU Bo. A Bayesian meta-analysis of the association between AI literacy and self-efficacy [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(10): 1779-1794. |
| [10] | ZHANG Nan, LI Xukui. A meta-analysis of the irrelevant speech effect in complex language processing tasks [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(1): 60-82. |
| [11] | FAN Wei, CHENG Ying. The relationship between sadness and prosocial behavior: A three-level meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2026, 34(1): 83-96. |
| [12] | SUN Luwen, ZHOU Yue, JIANG Zhongqing. The functional brain networks of intergroup empathy bias: A meta-analysis based on fMRI studies [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2025, 33(8): 1306-1320. |
| [13] | ZHANG Lu, WANG Ziqian, ZHANG Qingfang. Cognitive mechanisms underlying the age of acquisition effects: Insights from a three-level meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2025, 33(7): 1199-1220. |
| [14] | LI Ying, ZHAI Yihui, HAO Shoubin, DAI Yaxing, MA Xiaobo, LI Tiantian, WANG Yue. Embodiment effect in second language and its influences: Evidence based on meta-analysis [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2025, 33(7): 1221-1233. |
| [15] | XUE Xiaoran, CUI Wei, ZHANG Li. A three-level meta-analysis of gender differences in spatial navigation ability [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2025, 33(5): 843-862. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||