注意缺陷多动障碍-发展性阅读障碍共患儿童的干预效果及其内在机理

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1042.2023.00622

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 注意缺陷多动障碍和发展性阅读障碍是两类常见的儿童神经发育障碍, 二者共患率高达25%~48%。共患问题不仅使儿童自身面临着严重的认知、行为和心理损害, 还给家庭、学校和社会带来了沉重的负担, 对共患儿童的干预是极为必要且重要的。以共患病理机制假说为基础, 可将既往共患儿童的干预研究划分为以下两大类：(1)基于表型假说的干预方案, 如药物干预、阅读干预以及二者联合干预, 相应方案干预效果的迁移性和稳定性均有待深入考究; (2)基于共同缺陷假说的干预方案, 如针对核心共同认知缺陷之一的加工速度问题的干预已初显成效, 但相关研究较少, 干预效果需更多研究进一步系统性地考察。最后就共患儿童的干预方案现状进行了反思和展望。

关键词: 注意缺陷多动障碍, 发展性阅读障碍, 共患, 干预, 认知训练

Abstract: Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and developmental dyslexia (DD) are two common neurodevelopmental disorders in children, and the prevalence of the comorbidity between these two disorders varies from 25% to 48%. This comorbidity not only exposes children to cognitive, behavioral, and psychological impairments but also brings a heavy burden to their families, schools, and society. Hence, intervention for children with comorbidity between ADHD and DD is extremely important and necessary. Based on the hypothesis regarding the pathological mechanism of this comorbidity, previous intervention studies can be divided into two categories as below: 1) Intervention programs based on the phenotype hypothesis, that is, the intervention targeting the core deficits in one of ADHD and DD is predicted to improve the symptoms of the other disorder. For example, the usage of pharmacological intervention targeting ADHD symptoms, or reading intervention targeting dyslexia, or the combination of the two interventions. These intervention programs have been found to exhibit direct benefits on the targeted disorder, but relevant transfer effect and retention effect especially on the symptoms of the other disorder still need to be further checked and examined. Moreover, the combined programs of medication and reading intervention have additive effects as compared to the intervention program targeting only one disorder, but no incremental effect has been found. This lack of interaction of the intervention effects challenges the phenotype hypothesis to some extent. 2) Intervention programs based on the common deficit hypothesis. For example, preliminary benefits have been found in the intervention focusing on processing speed, that is, one of the critical common deficits between ADHD and DD, in which the significantly transfer effect has been observed. Although relevant intervention studies targeting common deficits between ADHD and DD are scarce, previous findings supported the feasibility of these intervention programs and provide some enlightenment for future direction. More studies can be further carried out from the following aspects: Firstly, to design intervention of the comorbidity based on the theoretical hypotheses. On the one hand, it is better to extensively explore the potential core factors regarding the common deficits between ADHD and DD so as to examine the etiology of the comorbidity and to design relevant cognitive training programs; on the other hand, future studies should utilize various types of intervention programs on the basis of the phenotype hypothesis, so as to fully verify the hypothesis and comprehensively investigate the training effects of the corresponding intervention programs. Secondly, more studies with multi-modal techniques are required to explore the etiology of the comorbidity, to systematically evaluate the training effects from the direct, transfer, and retention effects, as well as the possible mechanism underlying the training benefits. Finally, parental intervention and teacher training should be integrated into the intervention system for the children with ADHD-DD comorbidity to form a child-parent-school community, with contributing to the development of these comorbided children via a home-school cooperation.

Key words: attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, developmental dyslexia, comorbidity, intervention, cognitive training

中图分类号:

R395

崔楠, 王久菊, 赵婧. (2023). 注意缺陷多动障碍-发展性阅读障碍共患儿童的干预效果及其内在机理. 心理科学进展 , 31(4), 622-630.

CUI Nan, WANG Jiuju, ZHAO Jing. (2023). Effectiveness and underlying mechanism of the intervention for children with comorbidity between attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and developmental dyslexia. Advances in Psychological Science, 31(4), 622-630.

参考文献

[1] 胡俊, 冯雪英, 衣明纪, 王艳霞, 刘小梅, 马良. (2021). 发展性阅读障碍儿童行为特点及家长情绪状况病例对照研究.中国儿童保健杂志, 29(1), 18-22.
[2] 李焱, 文竹, 邓思宇, 江文庆, 范娟, 杜亚松. (2022). 盐酸哌甲酯缓释片与盐酸托莫西汀对注意缺陷多动障碍患儿症状与执行功能的疗效研究.中国儿童保健杂志, 30(12), 1291-1296.
[3] 刘杰, 孟会敏. (2009). 关于布郎芬布伦纳发展心理学生态系统理论.中国健康心理学杂志, 17(2), 250-252.
[4] 杨斌让. (2019). 注意缺陷多动障碍药物治疗.教育生物学杂志, 7(4), 199-206.
[5] 岳鑫鑫, 韩冬影, 李虹, 于玲, 王久菊, 王玉凤, ... 李宜逊. (2019). 程序化拼音游戏训练对注意缺陷多动障碍共患阅读障碍患儿干预效果的研究.中华精神科杂志, 52(2), 117-122.
[6] 钟鑫琪, 比沙拉, 胡晓云, 赵晓丽, 李秀红. (2019). 发育性阅读障碍和注意缺陷多动可疑儿童的情绪行为问题.中国学校卫生, 40(10), 1460-1463.
[7] Barkley, R. A. (1997). Behavioral inhibition, sustained attention, and executive functions: Constructing a unifying theory of ADHD.Psychological Bulletin, 121(1), 65-94.
[8] Bental, B., & Tirosh, E. (2008). The effects of methylphenidate on word decoding accuracy in boys with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology, 28(1), 89-92.
[9] Benzing, V., & Schmidt, M. (2019). The effect of exergaming on executive functions in children with ADHD: A randomized clinical trial.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports, 29(8), 1243-1253.
[10] Caldani S., Isel F., Septier M., Acquaviva E., & Bucci M. P. (2020). Impairment in attention focus during the posner cognitive task in children with ADHD: An eye tracker study.Frontiers in Pediatrics, 8, 484.
[11] Dehaene S., Pegado F., Braga L. W., Ventura P., Filho G. N., Jobert A., ... Cohen L. (2010). How learning to read changes the cortical networks for vision and language.Science, 330(6009), 1359-1364.
[12] de Jong, C. G. W., van de Voorde S., Roeyers H., Raymaekers R., Allen A. J., Knijff S., ... Sergeant J. A. (2009). Differential effects of atomoxetine on executive functioning and lexical decision in attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder and reading disorder.Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, 19(6), 699-707.
[13] Denton C. A., Tamm L., Schatschneider C., & Epstein J. N. (2020). The effects of ADHD treatment and reading intervention on the fluency and comprehension of children with ADHD and word reading difficulties: A randomized clinical trial.Scientific Studies of Reading, 24(1), 72-89.
[14] Dovis S., van der Oord S., Wiers R. W., & Prins, P. J. M. (2015). Improving executive functioning in children with ADHD: Training multiple executive functions within the context of a computer game. A randomized double-blind placebo controlled trial.PLoS ONE, 10(4), 1-30.
[15] Ebrahimi L., Pouretemad H., Khatibi A., & Stein J. (2019). Magnocellular based visual motion training improves reading in persian.Scientific Reports, 9(1), 1-10.
[16] Froehlich T. E., Fogler J., Barbaresi W. J., Elsayed N. A., Evans S. W., & Chan E. (2018). Using ADHD medications to treat coexisting ADHD and reading disorders: A systematic review.Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 104(4), 619-637.
[17] Gomes H., Duff M., Ramos M., Molholm S., Foxe J. J., & Halperin J. (2012). Auditory selective attention and processing in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.Clinical Neurophysiology, 123(2), 293-302.
[18] Gonçalves-Guedim, T. F., & Crenitte P. A. P. (2015). Performance of phonological processing in children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.Psychology, 6(10), 1331-1339.
[19] Gooch D., Snowling M., & Hulme C. (2011). Time perception, phonological skills and executive function in children with dyslexia and/or ADHD symptoms.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 52(2), 195-203.
[20] Goradia D. D., Vogel S., Mohl B., Khatib D., Zajac- Benitez C., Rajan U., ... Stanley J. A. (2016). Distinct differences in striatal dysmorphology between attention deficit hyperactivity disorder boys with and without a comorbid reading disability.Psychiatry Research Neuroimaging, 258, 30-36.
[21] Horowitz-Kraus, T. (2015). Differential effect of cognitive training on executive functions and reading abilities in children with ADHD and in children with ADHD comorbid with reading difficulties.Journal of Attention Disorders, 19(6), 515-526.
[22] Keulers E. H. H., Hendriksen J. G. M., Feron F. J. M., Wassenberg R., Wuisman-Frerker M. G. F., Jolles J., & Vles, J. S. H. (2007). Methylphenidate improves reading performance in children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and comorbid dyslexia: An unblinded clinical trial.European Journal of Paediatric Neurology, 11(1), 21-28.
[23] Kibby M. Y., Dyer S. M., Lee S. E., & Stacy M. (2020). Frontal volume as a potential source of the comorbidity between attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and reading disorders.Behavioural Brain Research, 381, 112-382.
[24] Kibby M. Y., Newsham G., Imre Z., & Schlak J. E. (2021). Is executive dysfunction a potential contributor to the comorbidity between basic reading disability and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder? Child Neuropsychology, 27(7), 888-910.
[25] Kibby M. Y., Pavawalla S. P., Fancher J. B., Naillon A. J., & Hynd G. W. (2009). The relationship between cerebral hemisphere volume and receptive language functioning in dyslexia and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).Journal of Child Neurology, 24(4), 438-448.
[26] Klingberg T., Fernell E., Olesen P. J., Johnson M., Gustafsson P., Dahlström K., ... Westerberg H. (2005). Computerized training of working memory in children with ADHD - A randomized, controlled trial.Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 44(2), 177-186.
[27] Kollins S. H., DeLoss D. J., Cañadas E., Lutz J., Findling R. L., Keefe R. S. E., ... Faraone S. V. (2020). A novel digital intervention for actively reducing severity of paediatric ADHD (STARS-ADHD): A randomised controlled trial.The Lancet Digital Health, 2(4), e168-e178.
[28] Langer N., Benjamin C., Becker B. L. C., & Gaab N. (2019). Comorbidity of reading disabilities and ADHD: Structural and functional brain characteristics.Human Brain Mapping, 40(9), 2677-2698.
[29] Low A. M., Vangkilde S., Le Sommer J., Fagerlund B., Glenthøj B., Jepsen J. R. M., ... Habekost T. (2019). Visual attention in adults with attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder before and after stimulant treatment.Psychological Medicine, 49(15), 2617-2625.
[30] Lyon G. R., Shaywitz S. E., & Shaywitz B. A. (2003). A definition of dyslexia.Annals of Dyslexia, 53(1), 1-14.
[31] Mayes, S. D., & Calhoun, S. L. (2007). Learning, attention, writing, and processing speed in typical children and children with ADHD, autism, anxiety, depression, and oppositional-defiant disorder.Child Neuropsychology, 13(6), 469-493.
[32] McGrath L. M., Pennington B. F., Shanahan M. A., Santerre-Lemmon L. E., Barnard H. D., Willcutt E. G., ... Olson R. K. (2011). A multiple deficit model of reading disability and attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder: Searching for shared cognitive deficits.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 52(5), 547-557.
[33] McGrath, L. M., & Stoodley, C. J. (2019). Are there shared neural correlates between dyslexia and ADHD? A meta-analysis of voxel-based morphometry studies.Journal of Neurodevelopmental Disorders, 11(1), 1-20.
[34] Meppelink R., de Bruin E. I., & Bögels S. M. (2016). Meditation or Medication? Mindfulness training versus medication in the treatment of childhood ADHD: A randomized controlled trial.BMC Psychiatry, 16(1), 1-16.
[35] Miranda A., Tárraga R., Fernández M. I., Colomer C., & Pastor G. (2015). Parenting stress in families of children with autism spectrum disorder and ADHD.Exceptional Children, 82(1), 81-95.
[36] Pecini C., Spoglianti S., Bonetti S., Di Lieto M. C., Guaran F., Martinelli A., ... Chilosi A. M. (2019). Training RAN or reading? A telerehabilitation study on developmental dyslexia. Dyslexia, 25(3), 318-331.
[37] Pennington, B. F. (2006). From single to multiple deficit models of developmental disorders.Cognition, 101(2), 385-413.
[38] Pennington B. F., Groisser D., & Welsh M. C. (1993). Contrasting cognitive deficits in attention deficit hyperactivity disorder versus reading disability.Developmental Psychology, 29(3), 511-523.
[39] Poon, K., & Ho, C. S. H. (2014). Contrasting deficits on executive functions in Chinese delinquent adolescents with attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder symptoms and/or reading disability.Research in Developmental Disabilities, 35(11), 3046-3056.
[40] Qian, Y., & Bi, H. Y. (2015). The effect of magnocellular- based visual-motor intervention on Chinese children with developmental dyslexia.Frontiers in Psychology, 6, 1529.
[41] Rabiner D. L., Malone P. S., Bierman K. L., Coie J. D., Dodge K. A., Foster E. M., ... Pinderhughes E. (2004). The impact of tutoring on early reading achievement for children with and without attention problems.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 32(3), 273-284.
[42] Rabiner D. L., Murray D. W., Skinner A. T., & Malone P. S. (2010). A randomized trial of two promising computer-based interventions for students with attention difficulties.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 38(1), 131-142.
[43] Ramus F., Rosen S., Dakin S. C., Day B. L., Castellote J. M., White S., & Frith U. (2003). Theories of developmental dyslexia: Insights from a multiple case study of dyslexic adults.Brain, 126(4), 841-865.
[44] Roberts G., Rane S., Fall A. M., Denton C. A., Fletcher J. M., & Vaughn S. (2015). The impact of intensive reading intervention on level of attention in middle school students.Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 44(6), 942-953.
[45] Rucklidge, J. J., & Tannock, R. (2002). Neuropsychological profiles of adolescents with ADHD: Effects of reading difficulties and gender.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 43(8), 988-1003.
[46] Semrud-Clikeman, M., & Bledsoe, J. (2011). Updates on attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and learning disorders.Current Psychiatry Reports, 13(5), 364-373.
[47] Sexton C. C., Gelhorn H. L., Bell J. A., & Classi P. M. (2012). The co-occurrence of reading disorder and ADHD: Epidemiology, treatment, psychosocial impact, and economic burden.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 45(6), 538-564.
[48] Shanahan M. A., Pennington B. F., Yerys B. E., Scott A., Boada R., Willcutt E. G., ... DeFries J. C. (2006). Processing speed deficits in attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder and reading disability.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 34(5), 584-601.
[49] Shaywitz B. A., Williams D. W., Fox B. K., & Wietecha L. A. (2014). Reading outcomes of children and adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and dyslexia following atomoxetine treatment.Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, 24(8), 419-425.
[50] Shaywitz S., Shaywitz B., Wietecha L., Wigal S., McBurnett K., Williams D., .. Hooper S. R. (2017). Effect of atomoxetine treatment on reading and phonological skills in children with dyslexia or attention-Deficit/ hyperactivity disorder and comorbid dyslexia in a randomized, placebo-controlled trial.Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, 27(1), 19-28.
[51] Stefanac N., Spencer-Smith M., Brosnan M., Vangkilde S., Castles A., & Bellgrove M. (2019). Visual processing speed as a marker of immaturity in lexical but not sublexical dyslexia.Cortex, 120, 567-581.
[52] Storebø O. J., Krogh H. B., Ramstad E., Moreira-Maia C. R., Holmskov M., Skoog M., ... Gluud C. (2015). Methylphenidate for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in children and adolescents: Cochrane systematic review with meta-analyses and trial sequential analyses of randomised clinical trials. British Medical Journal, 351, h5203.
[53] Tamm L., Denton C. A., Epstein J. N., Schatschneider C., Taylor H., Arnold L. E., ... Vaughn A. (2017). Comparing treatments for children with ADHD and word reading difficulties: A randomized clinical trial.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 85(5), 434-446.
[54] Tamm L., Epstein J. N., Peugh J. L., Nakonezny P. A., & Hughes C. W. (2013). Preliminary data suggesting the efficacy of attention training for school-aged children with ADHD.Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 4, 16-28.
[55] Tannock R., Frijters J. C., Martinussen R., White E. J., Ickowicz A., Benson N. J., & Lovett M. W. (2018). Combined modality intervention for ADHD with comorbid reading disorders: A proof of concept study.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 51(1), 55-72.
[56] Tannock R., Martinussen R., & Frijters J. (2000). Naming speed performance and stimulant effects indicate effortful, semantic processing deficits in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 28(3), 237-252.
[57] Valdois S., Peyrin C., Lassus-Sangosse D., Lallier M., Démonet J. F., & Kandel S. (2014). Dyslexia in a French-Spanish bilingual girl: Behavioural and neural modulations following a visual attention span intervention.Cortex, 53(1), 120-145.
[58] Wang, L. C., & Chung, K. K. H. (2018). Co-morbidities in Chinese children with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder and reading disabilities.Dyslexia, 24(3), 276-293.
[59] Whipple, B. D., & Nelson, J. M. (2016). Naming speed of adolescents and young adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: Differences in alphanumeric versus color/object naming.Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology, 31(1), 66-78.
[60] Wietecha L., Williams D., Shaywitz S., Shaywitz B., Hooper S. R., Wigal S. B., ... McBurnett K. (2013). Atomoxetine improved attention in children and adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and dyslexia in a 16 week, acute, randomized, double-blind trial.Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, 23(9), 605-613.
[61] Willcutt E. G., Betjemann R. S., McGrath L. M., Chhabildas N. A., Olson R. K., DeFries J. C., & Pennington B. F. (2010). Etiology and neuropsychology of comorbidity between RD and ADHD: The case for multiple-deficit models.Cortex, 46(10), 1345-1361.
[62] Willcutt E. G., Doyle A. E., Nigg J. T., Faraone S. V., & Pennington B. F. (2005). Validity of the executive function theory of attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder: A meta-analytic review.Biological Psychiatry, 57(11), 1336-1346.
[63] Willcutt, E. G., & Pennington, B. F. (2000). Psychiatric comorbidity in children and adolescents with reading disability.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 41(8), 1039-1048.
[64] Willcutt E. G., Pennington B. F., Boada R., Ogline J. S., Tunick R. A., Chhabildas N. A., & Olson R. K. (2001). A comparison of the cognitive deficits in reading disability and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 110(1), 157-172.
[65] Willcutt E. G., Pennington B. F., Olson R. K., Chhabildas N., & Hulslander J. (2005). Neuropsychological analyses of comorbidity between reading disability and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: In search of the common deficit.Developmental Neuropsychology, 27(1), 35-78.
[66] Zhao J., Liu H., Li J., Sun H., Liu Z., Gao J., Liu Y., & Huang C. (2019). Improving sentence reading performance in Chinese children with developmental dyslexia by training based on visual attention span.Scientific Reports, 9(1), 1-19.