The negative effects of empowering leadership: Theoretical mechanisms and boundary conditions

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1042.2019.00858

Abstract

Abstract:

Despite previous research primarily focused on the positive outcomes resulting from empowering leadership, recent studies in this realm have indicated that empowering leadership could also bring potential negative effects apart from the positive outcomes. With respect to this issue, we first demonstrated the conceptualization and core characteristics of empowering leadership. Then, based on dual-task processing effect, role theory and implicit leadership theory, we explained the theoretical mechanisms of the negative effects of empowering leadership. Next, we analyzed the boundary conditions under which empowering leadership exerts positive influence on employees and organizations. Finally, we proposed several future research directions regarding the negative effects of empowering leadership.

Key words: empowering leadership, negative effects, theoretical mechanisms, boundary conditions

CLC Number:

B849:C93

WANG Honglei, SUN Jianmin. The negative effects of empowering leadership: Theoretical mechanisms and boundary conditions[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2019, 27(5): 858-870.

References 84

[1]	曹元坤, 祝振兵 . ( 2015). 内隐追随理论: 概念, 测量, 前因及后果. 心理科学进展, 23( 2), 280-288.
[2]	陈国权, 陈子栋 . ( 2017). 领导授权行为对员工学习能力影响机制研究. 科研管理, 38( 3), 114-127.
[3]	陈默, 梁建 . ( 2017). 高绩效要求与亲组织不道德行为: 基于社会认知理论的视角. 心理学报, 49( 1), 94-105.
[4]	高中华, 赵晨 . ( 2015). 知识员工角色压力对生活满意度的影响研究——一个被调节的中介效应模型. 科研管理, 36( 11), 162-169.
[5]	蒿坡, 龙立荣, 贺伟 . ( 2014). 领导力共享, 垂直领导力与团队创造力: 双视角研究. 管理科学, 27( 6), 53-64.
[6]	何燕珍, 张瑞 . ( 2016). 授权型领导对服务类员工亲社会性违规行为的影响机理. 中国人力资源开发, ( 2), 17-28.
[7]	金家飞, 徐姗, 王艳霞 . ( 2014). 角色压力, 工作家庭冲突和心理抑郁的中美比较. 心理学报, 46( 8), 1144-1160.
[8]	林美珍, 罗忠恒 . ( 2017). 授权型领导负面效应的形成机制: 基于“过犹不及”理论. 首都经济贸易大学学报, 19( 5), 104-112.
[9]	彭坚, 王震 . ( 2017). 做上司的“意中人”: 负担还是赋能? 追随原型—特质匹配的双刃剑效应. 心理学报, 50( 2), 216-225.
[10]	孙圣兰, 吕洁 . ( 2016). 授权型领导对员工创造力的影响: 基于整合视角的分析. 研究与发展管理, 28( 4), 117-125.
[11]	王宏蕾, 孙健敏 . ( 2018). 授权型领导与员工创新行为: 结构正式化的调节作用. 管理科学, 31( 3), 29-39.
[12]	王永跃, 葛菁青, 张洋 . ( 2016). 授权型领导, 心理可得性与创新: 组织支持感的作用. 应用心理学, 22( 4), 304-312.
[13]	张华磊, 袁庆宏, 王震, 黄勇 . ( 2014). 核心自我评价, 领导风格对研发人员跨界行为的影响研究. 管理学报, 11( 8), 1168-1176.
[14]	Ahearne M., Mathieu J., & Rapp A . ( 2005). To empower or not to empower your sales force? An empirical examination of the influence of leadership empowerment behavior on customer satisfaction and performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 90( 5), 945-955.
[15]	Aktas M., Gelfand M. J., & Hanges P. J . ( 2016). Cultural tightness-looseness and perceptions of effective leadership. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 47( 2), 294-309. doi: 10.1177/0022022115606802 URL
[16]	Alicke M. D., & Sedikides C. ,( 2009). Self-enhancement and self-protection: What they are and what they do. European Review of Social Psychology, 20( 1), 1-48.
[17]	Amundsen S., & Martinsen Ø. L . ( 2014). Empowering leadership: Construct clarification, conceptualization, and validation of a new scale. The Leadership Quarterly, 25( 3), 487-511. doi: 10.1016/j.leaqua.2013.11.009 URL
[18]	Amundsen S., & Martinsen Ø L . ( 2015). Linking empowering leadership to job satisfaction, work effort, and creativity: The role of self-leadership and psychological empowerment. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 22( 3), 304-323.
[19]	Arnold J. A., Arad S., Rhoades J. A., & Drasgow F . ( 2000). The empowering leadership questionnaire: The construction and validation of a new scale for measuring leader behaviors. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 21( 3), 249-269. doi: 10.1002/(ISSN)1099-1379 URL
[20]	Bamberger P. A., Geller D., & Doveh E . ( 2017). Assisting upon entry: Helping type and approach as moderators of how role conflict affects newcomer resource drain. Journal of Applied Psychology, 102( 12), 1719-1732. doi: 10.1037/apl0000243 URL
[21]	Biemann T., Kearney E., & Marggraf K . ( 2015). Empowering leadership and managers' career perceptions: Examining effects at both the individual and the team level. The Leadership Quarterly, 26( 5), 775-789.
[22]	Buch R., Martinsen Ø. L., & Kuvaas B . ( 2015). The destructiveness of laissez-faire leadership behavior: The mediating role of economic leader-member exchange relationships. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 22( 1), 115-124.
[23]	Carnes A., Houghton J. D., & Ellison C. N . ( 2015). What matters most in leader selection? The role of personality and implicit leadership theories. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 36( 4), 360-379.
[24]	Cheong M., Spain S. M., Yammarino F. J., & Yun S . ( 2016). Two faces of empowering leadership: Enabling and burdening. The Leadership Quarterly, 27( 4), 602-616.
[25]	Conger J. A., & Kanungo R. N . ( 1988). The empowerment process: Integrating theory and practice. Academy of Management Review, 13( 3), 471-482. doi: 10.5465/amr.1988.4306983 URL
[26]	Cordery J. L., Morrison D., Wright B. M., & Wall T. D . ( 2010). The impact of autonomy and task uncertainty on team performance: A longitudinal field study. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 31( 2-3), 240-258.
[27]	Deery S., Walsh J., & Zatzick C. D . ( 2014). A moderated mediation analysis of job demands, presenteeism, and absenteeism. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 87( 2), 352-369.
[28]	Dong Y., Liao H., Chuang A., Zhou J., & Campbell E. M . ( 2015). Fostering employee service creativity: Joint effects of customer empowering behaviors and supervisory empowering leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology, 100( 5), 1364-1380.
[29]	Eden D., & Leviatan U. , ( 1975). Implicit leadership theory as a determinant of the factor structure underlying supervisory behavior scales. Journal of Applied Psychology, 60( 6), 736-741. doi: 10.1037/0021-9010.60.6.736 URL
[30]	Fong K. H., & Snape E. , ( 2015). Empowering leadership, psychological empowerment and employee outcomes: Testing a multi-level mediating model. British Journal of Management, 26( 1), 126-138.
[31]	Foti R. J., Hansbrough T. K., Epitropaki O., & Coyle P. T . ( 2017). Dynamic viewpoints on implicit leadership and followership theories: Approaches, findings, and future directions. The Leadership Quarterly, 28( 2), 261-267. doi: 10.1016/j.leaqua.2017.02.004 URL
[32]	Hackman J. R., & Oldham G. R . ( 1976). Motivation through the design of work: Test of a theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 16( 2), 250-279.
[33]	Hansbrough T. K., Lord R. G., & Schyns B . ( 2015). Reconsidering the accuracy of follower leadership ratings. The Leadership Quarterly, 26( 2), 220-237. doi: 10.1016/j.leaqua.2014.11.006 URL
[34]	Hao P., He W., & Long L. R . ( 2018). Why and when empowering leadership has different effects on employee work performance: The pivotal roles of passion for work and role breadth self-efficacy. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 25( 1), 85-100.
[35]	Harris T. B., Li N., Boswell W. R., Zhang X-A., & Xie Z . ( 2014). Getting what’s new from newcomers: Empowering leadership, creativity, and adjustment in the socialization context. Personnel Psychology, 67( 3), 567-604.
[36]	Hempel P. S., Zhang Z-X., & Han Y . ( 2012). Team empowerment and the organizational context: Decentralization and the contrasting effects of formalization. Journal of Management, 38( 2), 475-501.
[37]	Hill N. S., & Bartol K. M . ( 2016). Empowering leadership and effective collaboration in geographically dispersed teams. Personnel Psychology, 69( 1), 159-198.
[38]	Hinkin T. R., & Schriesheim C. A . ( 2008). An examination of “nonleadership”: From laissez-faire leadership to leader reward omission and punishment omission. Journal of Applied Psychology, 93( 6), 1234-1248. doi: 10.1037/a0012875 URL
[39]	Hmieleski K. M., & Ensley M. D . ( 2007). A contextual examination of new venture performance: Entrepreneur leadership behavior, top management team heterogeneity, and environmental dynamism. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 28( 7), 865-889. doi: 10.1002/(ISSN)1099-1379 URL
[40]	Hong Y., Liao H., Raub S., & Han J. H . ( 2016). What it takes to get proactive: An integrative multilevel model of the antecedents of personal initiative. Journal of Applied Psychology, 101( 5), 687-701. doi: 10.1037/apl0000064 URL
[41]	Humborstad S. I. W., & Kuvaas B. , ( 2013). Mutuality in leader-subordinate empowerment expectation: Its impact on role ambiguity and intrinsic motivation. The Leadership Quarterly, 24( 2), 363-377. doi: 10.1016/j.leaqua.2013.01.003 URL
[42]	Humborstad S. I. W., Humborstad B., Whitfield R., & Perry C . ( 2008). Implementation of empowerment in Chinese high power-distance organizations. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 19( 7), 1349-1364. doi: 10.1080/09585190802110224 URL
[43]	Humborstad S. I. W., Nerstad C. G. L., & Dysvik A . ( 2014). Empowering leadership, employee goal orientations and work performance: A competing hypothesis approach. Personnel Review, 43( 2), 246-271. doi: 10.1108/PR-01-2012-0008 URL
[44]	Jensen J. M., Patel P. C., & Messersmith J. G . ( 2013). High-performance work systems and job control: Consequences for anxiety, role overload, and turnover intentions. Journal of Management, 39( 6), 1699-1724.
[45]	Kahn R. L., Wolfe D. M., Quinn R. P., Snoek J. D., & Rosenthal R. A . ( 1964). Organizational stress: Studies in role conflict and ambiguity. New York: Wiley.
[46]	Kahn O-P., . ( 2014). So, what am I supposed to do? A multilevel examination of role clarity. Journal of Management Studies, 51( 5), 737-763.
[47]	Kim M., & Beehr T. A . ( 2017). Self-efficacy and psychological ownership mediate the effects of empowering leadership on both good and bad employee behaviors. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 24( 4), 466-478.
[48]	Kim M., Beehr T. A., & Prewett M. S . ( 2018). Employee responses to empowering leadership: A meta-analysis. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 25( 3), 257-276. doi: 10.1177/1548051817750538
[49]	Labianca G., Gray B., & Brass D. J . ( 2000). A grounded model of organizational schema change during empowerment. Organization Science, 11( 2), 235-257. doi: 10.1287/orsc.11.2.235.12512 URL
[50]	Lam C. K., Huang X & Chan S. C. H ., ( 2015). The threshold effect of participative leadership and the role of leader information sharing. Academy of Management Journal, 58( 3), 836-855. doi: 10.5465/amj.2013.0427 URL
[51]	Langfred C. W., & Moye N. A . ( 2004). Effects of task autonomy on performance: An extended model considering motivational, informational, and structural mechanisms. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89( 6), 934-945.
[52]	Leach D. J., Wall T. D., & Jackson P. R . ( 2003). The effect of empowerment on job knowledge: An empirical test involving operators of complex technology. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 76( 1), 27-52.
[53]	Lee A., Willis S., & Tian A. W . ( 2018). Empowering leadership: A meta-analytic examination of incremental contribution, mediation, and moderation. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 39( 3), 306-325.
[54]	Lee M. C. C., Idris M. A., & Delfabbro P. H . ( 2017). The linkages between hierarchical culture and empowering leadership and their effects on employees’ work engagement: Work meaningfulness as a mediator. International Journal of Stress Management, 24( 4), 392-415.
[55]	Lee S., Cheong M., Kim M., & Yun S . ( 2017). Never too much? The curvilinear relationship between empowering leadership and task performance. Group & Organization Management, 42( 1), 11-38.
[56]	Levy J. & Pashler H. , ( 2001). Is dual-task slowing instruction dependent? Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 27( 4), 862-869 doi: 10.1037/0096-1523.27.4.862 URL
[57]	Lewin K. , ( 1947). Group decision and social change. In T. M. Newcomb & E. L. Hartley (Eds.), Readings in Social Psychology( pp. 330-344). New York: Holt.
[58]	Li N., Chiaburu D. S., & Kirkman B. L . ( 2017). Cross- level influences of empowering leadership on citizenship behavior: Organizational support climate as a double- edged sword. Journal of Management, 43( 4), 1076-1102.
[59]	Lorinkova N. M., & Perry, S. J . ( 2017). When is empowerment effective? The role of leader-leader exchange in empowering leadership, cynicism, and time theft. Journal of Management, 43( 5), 1631-1654.
[60]	Lorinkova N. M., Pearsall M. J., & Sims H. P. Jr ., ( 2013). Examining the differential longitudinal performance of directive versus empowering leadership in teams. Academy of Management Journal, 56( 2), 573-596. doi: 10.5465/amj.2011.0132 URL
[61]	Magni M., & Maruping L. M . ( 2013). Sink or swim: Empowering leadership and overload in teams' ability to deal with the unexpected. Human Resource Management, 52( 5), 715-739.
[62]	Manz C. C., & Sims H. P. Jr . ( 1991). Superleadership: Beyond the myth of heroic leadership. Organizational Dynamics, 19( 4), 18-35.
[63]	Mariappanadar S., .( 2014). Stakeholder harm index: A framework to review work intensification from the critical HRM perspective. Human Resource Management Review, 24( 4), 313-329.
[64]	Martin S. L., Liao H., & Campbell E. M . ( 2013). Directive versus empowering leadership: A field experiment comparing impacts on task proficiency and proactivity. Academy of Management Journal, 56( 5), 1372-1395. doi: 10.5465/amj.2011.0113 URL
[65]	Mathieu J., Ahearne M., & Taylor S. R . ( 2007). A longitudinal cross-level model of leader and salesperson influences on sales force technology use and performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 92( 2), 528-537. doi: 10.1037/0021-9010.92.2.528 URL
[66]	Matthews R. A., Winkel D. E., & Wayne J. H . ( 2014). A longitudinal examination of role overload and work-family conflict: The mediating role of interdomain transitions. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 35( 1), 72-91.
[67]	Maynard M. T., Mathieu J. E., Marsh W. M., & Ruddy T. M . ( 2007). A multilevel investigation of the influences of employees’ resistance to empowerment. Human Performance, 20( 2), 147-171. doi: 10.1080/08959280701332885 URL
[68]	Menon S., . ( 2001). Employee empowerment: An integrative psychological approach. Applied psychology: An International Review, 50( 1), 153-180.
[69]	Mills P. K., & Ungson G. R . ( 2003). Reassessing the limits of structural empowerment: Organizational constitution and trust as controls. Academy of Management Review, 28( 1), 143-153.
[70]	Pearce C. L., Sims H. P., Jr. Cox J. F., Ball G., Schnell E., Smith K. A., & Trevino L . ( 2003). Transactors, transformers and beyond: A multi-method development of a theoretical typology of leadership. Journal of Management Development, 22( 4), 273-307.
[71]	Rizzo J. R., House R. J., & Lirtzman S. I . ( 1970). Role conflict and ambiguity in complex organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 15( 2), 150-163. doi: 10.2307/2391486 URL
[72]	Rubinstein J. S., Meyer D. E., & Evans J. E . ( 2001). Executive control of cognitive processes in task switching. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 27( 4), 763-797. doi: 10.1037/0096-1523.27.4.763 URL
[73]	Schmidt S., Roesler U., Kusserow T., & Rau R . ( 2014). Uncertainty in the workplace: Examining role ambiguity and role conflict, and their link to depression-A meta- analysis. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 23( 1), 91-106. doi: 10.1080/1359432X.2012.711523 URL
[74]	Schweitzer M. E., Ordóñez L., & Douma B . ( 2004). Goal setting as a motivator of unethical behavior. Academy of Management Journal, 47( 3), 422-432
[75]	Sharma P. N., & Kirkman B. L . ( 2015). Leveraging leaders: A literature review and future lines of inquiry for empowering leadership research. Group & Organization Management, 40( 2), 193-237.
[76]	Skogstad A., Hetland J., Glasø L., & Einarsen S . ( 2014). Is avoidant leadership a root cause of subordinate stress? Longitudinal relationships between laissez-faire leadership and role ambiguity. Work & Stress, 28( 4), 323-341.
[77]	Spreitzer G. M . ( 1995). Psychological empowerment in the workplace: Dimensions, measurement, and validation. Academy of Management Journal, 38( 5), 1442-1465.
[78]	Temprado J. J., Monno A., Laurent M., & Zanone P. G .,( 2001). A dynamical framework to understand performance trade-offs and interference in dual tasks. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 27( 6), 1303-1313. doi: 10.1037/0096-1523.27.6.1303 URL
[79]	van Dijke M., De Cremer D., Mayer D. M., & Van Quaquebeke N . ( 2012). When does procedural fairness promote organizational citizenship behavior? Integrating empowering leadership types in relational justice models. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 117( 2), 235-248.
[80]	Vecchio R. P., Justin J. E., & Pearce C. L . ( 2010). Empowering leadership: An examination of mediating mechanisms within a hierarchical structure. The Leadership Quarterly, 21( 3), 530-542.
[81]	Wallace J. C., Johnson P. D., Mathe K., & Paul J . ( 2011). Structural and psychological empowerment climates, performance, and the moderating role of shared felt accountability. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96( 4), 840-850. doi: 10.1037/a0022227 URL
[82]	Wong S. I., & Giessner S. R . ( 2018). The thin line between empowering and laissez-faire leadership: An expectancy- match perspective. Journal of Management, 44( 2), 757-783.
[83]	Zhang X., & Bartol K. M . ( 2010). Linking empowering leadership and employee creativity: The influence of psychological empowerment, intrinsic motivation, and creative process engagement. Academy of Management Journal, 53( 1), 107-128.
[84]	Zhang X., & Zhou J. , ( 2014). Empowering leadership, uncertainty avoidance, trust, and employee creativity: Interaction effects and a mediating mechanism. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 124( 2), 150-164.