ISSN 0439-755X
CN 11-1911/B
主办:中国心理学会
   中国科学院心理研究所
出版:科学出版社

心理学报 ›› 1984, Vol. 16 ›› Issue (1): 37-44.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

关于同化和对比错觉的实验研究

张厚粲;施岱安   

  1. 北京师范大学心理系 ,美国匹兹堡大学
  • 发布日期:1984-03-25 出版日期:1984-03-25
  • 通讯作者: 张厚粲

EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES ON ASSIMILATION AND CONTRAST ILLUSIONS

Zhang Hou-can;Diane J. Schiano Beijing Normal University University of Pittsburgh   

  • Online:1984-03-25 Published:1984-03-25

摘要: 本文以Delbouef同心圆错觉图为材料,应用认知方式,控制注意,改变刺激和注视条件等变量,在三个实验中考察了同化错觉和对比错觉在机制上的区别和联系。结果发现,场依存性认知方式特征与同化错觉有显著正相关,对比错觉反之。利用指示语控制被试注意于测验成分时,显著的错觉减弱只出现在对比图形中。此外,在一般指示下两种错觉都因背景成分减弱轮廓的亮度对比而减弱,但在选择性指示的条件下,类似减弱只出现在同化错觉中。视角加大时显著地减弱同化错觉,却加大对比错觉。使用“减弱错觉”方法,即在多次连续判断中减小错觉量只在超中央窝(大视角)的观看条件下有显著效应。所有这些结果都难于用错觉产生的生理学模式和单因素认知模式来说明。因此,我们认为错觉是一种复杂的知觉加工活动的产物。在已有的各种错觉理论中,合成的认知性“集合与存储”模式(“Pool and Store Model”,Coren & Girgus,1978)似乎是最好的解释。

关键词: NULL

Abstract: Psychological, stcategic, and stimulus differentiation variables areusedto examine the nature of the functional relation between assimilation andcontrast distortions jn three experiments using the Delbouef (concentriccircle)illusion configurations. In Experiment Ⅰ, field dependence was foundto correlate positively with assimilation, but negatively with contrast, distor-tion magnitude in individuals. In Experiment Ⅱ, significant distortion reduc-tion was observed when observers were instructed to selectively attend tothe test element but only for the contrast configuration. In addition, observersgiven standard in.structions showed reductions in both distortions with loweredcontrast contour reflectance contrast, but those given selective attentioninstructions showed a similar reduction only in the assimilation distortion.InExperiment Ⅲ,suprafoveal (as opposed to subfoveal) viewing significantlyreduced the assimilation, but maximized the contrast, distortion. Moreover,significant distortion reduction with the "illusion decrement" procedure wasobserved only in suprafoveal conditions. The rate of dectement over trialsdiffered for the assimilation and contrast distortions, This pattern of findingsis best accounted for in terms of the composite congitive "Pool and Store"model, in which processes influencing Perceptual organization determine boththe type of distortion that is initially observed and the effectiveness of stra-tegic differentiation manipulations in reducing distortion magnitude.

Key words: NULL