The effects of positive contact and negative contact on intergroup relations

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1042.2020.00316

Abstract

Abstract:

Considering the fact that there is a ‘positive bias’ in previous intergroup contact research, negative contact has also been taken into consideration simultaneously. Currently, questionnaire, content analysis, social network analysis and experiment are the four main research methods used in research considering both positive and negative contact. It is demonstrated that positive contact and negative contact exerted positive and negative effects on intergroup relations respectively, which were mediated by intergroup emotion and intergroup trust, and moderated by authoritarianism and intimacy. On the relationship between positive and negative contact effects, two kinds of research ideas were employed, that is, asymmetry and interaction, both of which were supported by empirical evidence. In future research, it is necessary to examine the generalization effects of different valenced contact, especially negative contact, expand the effect scope of positive and negative contact, perfect the mechanism of positive and negative contact, and further explore the factors that affect the asymmetric effect of positive and negative contact.

Key words: positive contact, negative contact, positive bias, asymmetry effect, interaction effect

CLC Number:

B849: C91

ZHAO Hebin, WANG Changcheng, XIA Mian, WANG Xujie. The effects of positive contact and negative contact on intergroup relations[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2020, 28(2): 316-328.

References 80

[1]	李爱梅, 高结怡, 彭元, 夏萤, 陈晓曦 . ( 2015). 积极情感和消极情感适应的不对称性及其机制探讨. 心理科学进展, 23( 4), 632-642.
[2]	李琼, 郭永玉 . ( 2007). 作为偏见影响因素的权威主义人格. 心理科学进展, 15( 6), 981-986.
[3]	李森森, 龙长权, 陈庆飞, 李红 . ( 2010). 群际接触理论——一种改善群际关系的理论. 心理科学进展, 18( 5), 831-839.
[4]	Aberson, C. L . ( 2015). Positive intergroup contact, negative intergroup contact, and threat as predictors of cognitive and affective dimensions of prejudice. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 18( 6), 743-760.
[5]	Alperin, A., Hornsey, M. J., Hayward, L. E., Diedrichs, P. C., & Barlow, F. K . ( 2014). Applying the contact hypothesis to anti-fat attitudes: Contact with overweight people is related to how we interact with our bodies and those of others. Social Science & Medicine, 123, 37-44.
[6]	Al Ramiah, A., & Hewstone, M . ( 2013). Intergroup contact as a tool for reducing, resolving, and preventing intergroup conflict: Evidence, limitations, and potential. American Psychologist, 68( 7), 527-542.
[7]	Altemeyer, R. A . ( 1981). Right-wing authoritarianism. Winnipeg: University of Manitoba press.
[8]	Andrews, N. P., Yogeeswaran, K., Walker, M. J., & Hewstone, M . ( 2018). Effect of valenced vicarious online contact on out-group prejudice and perceived out-group variability: A study of online poker. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 48( 10), 571-581.
[9]	Árnadóttir, K., Lolliot, S., Brown, R., & Hewstone, M . ( 2018). Positive and negative intergroup contact: Interaction not asymmetry. European Journal of Social Psychology, 48( 11), 784-800.
[10]	Bagci, S. C., & Gungor, H . ( 2019). Associations between perceived positive and negative parental contact and adolescents’ intergroup contact experiences. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 69, 76-86.
[11]	Barlow, F. K., Paolini, S., Pedersen, A., Hornsey, M. J., Radke, H. R., Harwood, J., ... Sibley, C. G . ( 2012). The contact caveat: Negative contact predicts increased prejudice more than positive contact predicts reduced prejudice. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38( 12), 1629-1643.
[12]	Baumeister, R. F., Bratslavsky, E., Finkenauer, C., & Vohs, K. D . ( 2001). Bad is stronger than good. Review of General Psychology, 5( 4), 323-370.
[13]	Bergkvist, L., & Rossiter, J. R . ( 2007). The predictive validity of multiple-item versus single-item measures of the same constructs. Journal of Marketing Research, 44( 2), 175-184.
[14]	Birtel, M. D., & Crisp, R. J . ( 2012). “Treating” prejudice: An exposure-therapy approach to reducing negative reactions toward stigmatized groups. Psychological Science, 23( 11), 1379-1386.
[15]	Brown, R., & Hewstone, M . ( 2005). An integrative theory of intergroup contact. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 37( 5), 255-343.
[16]	Brylka, A., Jasinskaja-Lahti, I., & Mähönen, T. A . ( 2016). The majority influence on interminority attitudes: The secondary transfer effect of positive and negative contact. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 50, 76-88.
[17]	Cernat, V . ( 2017). Trajectories of interethnic contact and prejudice in a four-waves study of Romanian teenager- parent pairs. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 43( 15), 2669-2687.
[18]	Davies, K., Tropp, L. R., Aron, A., Pettigrew, T. F., & Wright, S. C . ( 2011). Cross-group friendships and intergroup attitudes: A meta-analytic review. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 15( 4), 332-351.
[19]	Desforges, D. M., Lord, C. G., Ramsey, S. L., Mason, J. A., van Leeuwen, M. D., West, S. C., Lepper, M. R . ( 1991). Effects of structured cooperative contact on changing negative attitudes toward stigmatized social groups. Journal of Personality and Social psychology, 60( 4), 531-544.
[20]	Dhont, K., Hodson, G., Costello, K., & MacInnis, C. C . ( 2014). Social dominance orientation connects prejudicial human-human and human-animal relations. Personality and Individual Differences, 61-62, 105-108.
[21]	Dhont, K., & van Hiel, A . ( 2009). We must not be enemies: Interracial contact and the reduction of prejudice among authoritarians. Personality and Individual Differences, 46( 2), 172-177.
[22]	Dixon, J., Durrheim, K., & Tredoux, C . ( 2005). Beyond the optimal contact strategy: A reality check for the contact hypothesis. American Psychologist, 60( 7), 697-711.
[23]	Dovidio, J. F., Love, A., Schellhaas, F. M. H., & Hewstone, M . ( 2017). Reducing intergroup bias through intergroup contact: Twenty years of progress and future directions. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, 20( 5), 606-620.
[24]	Drury, L., Abrams, D., Swift, H. J., Lamont, R. A., & Gerocova, K . ( 2017). Can caring create prejudice? An investigation of positive and negative intergenerational contact in care settings and the generalisation of blatant and subtle age prejudice to other older people. Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology, 27( 1), 65-82.
[25]	Fell, B . ( 2015). The interaction of positive and negative intergroup contact (Unpublished doctorial dissertation). University of Oxford.
[26]	Fuochi, G., Voci, A., Veneziani, C. A., Boin, J., Fell, B., & Hewstone, M . ( 2019). Is negative mass media news always associated with outgroup prejudice? The buffering role of direct contact. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, in press.
[27]	Graf, S., & Paolini, S . ( 2017). Investigating positive and negative intergroup contact: Rectifying a long-standing Positivity bias in the literature. In S. Vezzali & S. Stathi (Eds.), Intergroup contact theory: Recent developments and future directions (pp. 92-113). New York, NY: Routledge.
[28]	Graf, S., Paolini, S., & Rubin, M . ( 2014). Negative intergroup contact is more influential, but positive intergroup contact is more common: Assessing contact prominence and contact prevalence in five Central European countries. European Journal of Social Psychology, 44( 6), 536-547.
[29]	Graf, S., Paolini, S., & Rubin, M . ( 2019). Does intimacy counteract or amplify the detrimental effects of negative intergroup contact on attitudes? Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, in press.
[30]	Hayward, L. E . ( 2014). Contact with an Alien race: An experimental test of positive and negative intergroup contact on intergroup emotions and attitudes. Society of Australasian Social Psychologists Conference.
[31]	Hayward, L. E., Tropp, L. R., Hornsey, M. J., & Barlow, F. K . ( 2017). Toward a comprehensive understanding of intergroup contact: Descriptions and mediators of positive and negative contact among majority and minority groups. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 43( 3), 347-364.
[32]	Hayward, L. E., Tropp, L. R., Hornsey, M. J., & Barlow, F. K . ( 2018). How negative contact and positive contact with Whites predict collective action among racial and ethnic minorities. British Journal of Social Psychology, 57( 1), 1-20.
[33]	Joyce, N., & Harwood, J . ( 2014). Improving intergroup attitudes through televised vicarious intergroup contact: Social cognitive processing of ingroup and outgroup information. Communication Research, 41( 5), 627-643.
[34]	Kanas, A., Scheepers, P., & Sterkens, C . ( 2017). Positive and negative contact and attitudes towards the religious out-group: Testing the contact hypothesis in conflict and non-conflict regions of Indonesia and the Philippines. Social Science Research, 63, 95-110.
[35]	Kauff, M., Asbrock, F., Wagner, U., Pettigrew, T. F., Hewstone, M., Schäfer, S. J., & Christ, O . ( 2017). ( Bad) feelings about meeting them? Episodic and chronic intergroup emotions associated with positive and negative intergroup contact as predictors of intergroup behavior. Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 1449.
[36]	Kauff, M., Schmid, K., Lolliot, S., Al Ramiah, A. A., & Hewstone, M . ( 2016). Intergroup contact effects via ingroup distancing among majority and minority groups: Moderation by social dominance orientation. PloS one, 11( 1), e0146895.
[37]	Koopmans, R., & Veit, S . ( 2014). Ethnic diversity, trust, and the mediating role of positive and negative interethnic contact: A priming experiment. Social Science Research, 47, 91-107.
[38]	Kteily, N., Ho, A. K., & Sidanius, J . ( 2012). Hierarchy in the mind: The predictive power of social dominance orientation across social contexts and domains. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 48( 2), 543-549.
[39]	Kteily, N. S., Hodson, G., Dhont, K., & Ho, A. K . ( 2017). Predisposed to prejudice but responsive to intergroup contact? Testing the unique benefits of intergroup contact across different types of individual differences. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 22( 1), 3-25.
[40]	Laurence, J., Schmid, K., & Hewstone, M . ( 2018). Ethnic diversity, inter-group attitudes and countervailing pathways of positive and negative inter-group contact: An analysis across workplaces and neighbourhoods. Social Indicators Research, 136( 2), 719-749.
[41]	Lemmer, G., & Wagner, U . ( 2015). Can we really reduce ethnic prejudice outside the lab? A meta-analysis of direct and indirect contact interventions. European Journal of Social Psychology, 45( 2), 152-168.
[42]	Lewicki, R. J., McAllister, D. J., & Bies, R. J . ( 1998). Trust and distrust: New relationships and realities. Academy of Management Review, 23( 3), 438-458.
[43]	Mähönen, T. A., & Jasinskaja-Lahti, I . ( 2016). Ramifications of positive and negative contact experiences among remigrants from Russia to Finland. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 22( 2), 247-255.
[44]	Mazziotta, A., Rohmann, A., Wright, S. C., De Tezanos-Pinto, P., & Lutterbach, S . ( 2015). ( How) does positive and negative extended cross-group contact predict direct cross-group contact and intergroup attitudes?. European Journal of Social Psychology, 45( 5), 653-667.
[45]	Meleady, R., & Forder, L . ( 2018). When contact goes wrong: Negative intergroup contact promotes generalized outgroup avoidance. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, 22( 5), 688-707.
[46]	Meleady, R., Seger, C. R., & Vermue, M . ( 2017). Examining the role of positive and negative intergroup contact and anti-immigrant prejudice in Brexit. British Journal of Social Psychology, 56( 4), 799-808.
[47]	Meleady, R., & Vermue, M . ( 2019). The effect of intergroup contact on solidarity-based collective action is mediated by reductions in SDO. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 49(5), 307-318.
[48]	Miles, E., & Crisp, R. J . ( 2014). A meta-analytic test of the imagined contact hypothesis. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 17( 1), 3-26.
[49]	Pagotto, L., & Voci, A . ( 2013). Direct and mass-mediated contact: The role of different intergroup emotions. Testing Psychometrics Methodology in Applied Psychology, 20, 365-381.
[50]	Paolini, S., Harwood, J., Hewstone, M., & Neumann, D. L . ( 2018). Seeking and avoiding intergroup contact: Future frontiers of research on building social integration. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 12( 12), e12422.
[51]	Paolini, S., Harwood, J., & Rubin, M . ( 2010). Negative intergroup contact makes group memberships salient: Explaining why intergroup conflict endures. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 36( 12), 1723-1738.
[52]	Paolini, S., Harwood, J., Rubin, M., Husnu, S., Joyce, N., & Hewstone, M . ( 2014). Positive and extensive intergroup contact in the past buffers against the disproportionate impact of negative contact in the present. European Journal of Social Psychology, 44( 6), 548-562.
[53]	Paolini, S., Hewstone, M., Voci, A., Harwood, J., & Cairns, E . ( 2006). Intergroup contact and the promotion of intergroup harmony: The influence of intergroup emotions In R Brown & D Capozza (Eds) Social identities: Motivational, emotional, and cultural influences (pp 209-238) Hove, E. Sussex: Psychology Press.
[54]	Pettigrew, T. F . ( 1998). Intergroup contact theory. Annual Review of Psychology, 49( 1), 65-85.
[55]	Pettigrew, T. F . ( 2008). Future directions for intergroup contact theory and research. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 32( 3), 187-199.
[56]	Pettigrew, T. F., & Meertens, R. W . ( 1995). Subtle and blatant prejudice in Western Europe. European Journal of Social Psychology, 25( 1), 57-75.
[57]	Pettigrew, T. F., & Tropp, L. R . ( 2006). A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90( 5), 751-783.
[58]	Pettigrew, T. F., & Tropp, L. R . ( 2008). How does intergroup contact reduce prejudice? Meta-analytic tests of three mediators. European Journal of Social Psychology, 38( 6), 922-934.
[59]	Pettigrew, T. F., & Tropp, L. R . ( 2011). When groups meet: The dynamics of intergroup contact New York: Psychology Press The dynamics of intergroup contact. New York: Psychology Press.
[60]	Pettigrew, T. F., Tropp, L. R., Wagner, U., & Christ, O . ( 2011). Recent advances in intergroup contact theory. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 35( 3), 271-280.
[61]	Ramiah, A. A., Hewstone, M., Little, T. D., & Lang, K . ( 2014). The influence of status on the relationship between intergroup contact, threat, and prejudice in the context of a nation-building intervention in Malaysia. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 58( 7), 1202-1229.
[62]	Reimer, N. K., Becker, J. C., Benz, A., Christ, O., Dhont, K., Klocke, U., ... & Hewstone, M . ( 2017). Intergroup contact and social change: Implications of negative and positive contact for collective action in advantaged and disadvantaged groups. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 43( 1), 121-136.
[63]	Reynolds, K. J., Turner, J. C., & Haslam, S. A . ( 2000). When are we better than them and they worse than us? A closer look at social discrimination in positive and negative domains. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78( 1), 64-80.
[64]	Rupar, M., Graf, S . ( 2018). Different forms of intergroup contact with former adversary are linked to distinct reconciliatory acts through symbolic and realistic threat. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 49( 2), 63-74.
[65]	Seger, C. R., Banerji, I., Park, S. H., Smith, E. R., & Mackie, D. M . ( 2016). Specific emotions as mediators of the effect of intergroup contact on prejudice: Findings across multiple participant and target groups. Cognition and Emotion, 31( 5), 1-14.
[66]	Stark, T. H., Flache, A., & Veenstra, R . ( 2013). Generalization of positive and negative attitudes toward individuals to outgroup attitudes. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 39( 5), 608-622.
[67]	Stephan, C. W., Stephan, W. G., Demitrakis, K. M., Yamada, A. M., & Clason, D. L . ( 2000). Women's attitudes toward men: An integrated threat theory approach. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 24( 1), 63-73.
[68]	Stephan, W. G., & Stephan, C. W . ( 1985). Intergroup anxiety. Journal of Social Issues, 41( 3), 157-175.
[69]	Techakesari, P., Barlow, F. K., Hornsey, M. J., Sung, B., Thai, M., & Chak, J. L. Y . ( 2015). An investigation of positive and negative contact as predictors of intergroup attitudes in the United States, Hong Kong, and Thailand. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 46( 3), 454-468.
[70]	Vedder, P., Wenink, E., & van Geel, M . ( 2017). Intergroup contact and prejudice between Dutch majority and Muslim minority youth in the Netherlands. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 23( 4), 477-485.
[71]	Visintin, E. P., Voci, A., Pagotto, L., & Hewstone, M . ( 2017). Direct, extended, and mass-mediated contact with immigrants in Italy: Their associations with emotions, prejudice, and humanity perceptions. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 47( 4), 175-194.
[72]	Wang, C., Fei, H., Stathi, S., & Vezzali, L . ( 2019). Positive and negative intergroup contact and willingness to engage in intergroup interactions among majority and minority group members in China: The moderating role of social dominance orientation. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, accepted.
[73]	Weise, D. R., Arciszewski, T., Verlhiac, J.-F., Pyszczynski, T., & Greenberg, J . ( 2012). Terror management and attitudes toward immigrants: Differential effects of mortality salience for low and high right-wing authoritarians. European Psychologist, 17( 1), 63-72.
[74]	Witt, P. L., & Wheeless, L. R . ( 2001). An experimental study of teachers’ verbal and nonverbal immediacy and students’ affective and cognitive learning. Communication Education, 50( 4), 327-342.
[75]	Wölfer, R., Faber, N. S., & Hewstone, M . ( 2015). Social network analysis in the science of groups: Cross-sectional and longitudinal applications for studying intra- and intergroup behavior. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice, 19( 1), 45-61.
[76]	Wölfer, R., Jaspers, E., Blaylock, D., Wigoder, C., Hughes, J., & Hewstone, M . ( 2017). Studying positive and negative direct and extended contact: Complementing self-reports with social network analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 43( 11), 1566-1581.
[77]	Wright, S. C., Aron, A., & Brody, S. M . ( 2008). Extended contact and including others in the self: Building on the Allport/Pettigrew legacy. In U. Wagner, L. R. Tropp, G. Finchilescu, & C. Tredoux (Eds.), Improving intergroup relations: Building on the legacy of Thomas F. Pettigrew (pp. 143-159). Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
[78]	Wright, S. C., Aron, A., Mclaughlin-Volpe, T., & Ropp, S. A . ( 1997). The extended contact effect: Knowledge of cross- group friendships and prejudice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73( 1), 73-90.
[79]	Wright, S. C., & Baray, G . ( 2012). Models of social change in social psychology: Collective action or prejudice reduction? Conflict or harmony? In J Dixon & M Levine (Eds), Beyond prejudice: Extending the social psychology of conflict, inequality and social change (pp 225-247). New York, NY, US: Cambridge University Press.
[80]	Zhou, S., Page-Gould, E., Aron, A., Moyer, A., & Hewstone, M . ( 2018). The extended contact hypothesis: A meta-analysis on 20 years of research. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 23( 2), 132-160.