Dynamic attention bias in social anxiety

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1042.2019.01887

Abstract

Abstract:

Attention bias is an important factor in the maintenance of Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD). Attentional vigilance, attentional avoidance, and difficulty in disengagement are the most widely studied and discussed ones. With the deepening of research, some researchers have suggested that the attention mode of SAD individuals is not a single and static mode, and it is more likely to switch between different attentional modes, which is a dynamic process. Based on relevant research results and theoretical assumptions, it is speculated that the attentional bias of SAD individuals will change dynamically with the increased anxiety level and impaired attention control ability, from attentional vigilance to the attention avoidance and difficulty in disengagement. This view needs further research to confirm and specify more targeted interventions based on the results of the study.

Key words: social anxiety, attention bias, attentional vigilance, attentional avoidance, difficulty in disengagement

CLC Number:

R395

JIANG Jingqi, WANG Haoyu, QIAN Mingyi. Dynamic attention bias in social anxiety[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2019, 27(11): 1887-1895.

Figures/Tables 4

References 43

1	American Psychiatric Association , ( 2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, fifth ed. American Psychiatric Association, Washington,DC.
2	Amir N., Elias J., Klumpp H., & Przeworski A . ( 2003). Attentional bias to threat in social phobia: Facilitated processing of threat or difficulty disengaging attention from threat?. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 41( 11), 1325-1335.
3	Bandelow, B., &Michaelis S. 2015). Epidemiology of anxiety disorders in the 21st century. Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience, 17( 3), 327-335.
4	Bantin T., Stevens S., Gerlach A. L., & Hermann C . ( 2016). What does the facial dot-probe task tell us about attentional processes in social anxiety? A systematic review. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 50, 40-51.
5	Buckner J. D., Maner J. K., & Schmidt N. B . ( 2010). Difficulty disengaging attention from social threat in social anxiety. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 34( 1), 99-105.
6	Chen Y. P., Ehlers A., Clark D. M., & Mansell W . ( 2002). Patients with generalized social phobia direct their attention away from faces. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 40( 6), 677-687.
7	Clark D. M. ,& Wells, A. (1995). A cognitive model of social phobia. In: R. G. Heimberg, M. R. Liebowitz, D. A. Hope, & F. R. Schneier (Eds.), Social phobia: Diagnosis, assessment, and treatment (pp. 69-93). New York, NY, US: Guilford Press.
8	Davis M. L., Rosenfield D., Bernstein A., Zvielli A., Reinecke A., Beevers C. G .,… Smits, J. A. J. . ( 2016). Attention bias dynamics and symptom severity during and following CBT for social anxiety disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 84( 9), 795-802.
9	Derryberry, D., &Reed,M. A . ( 2002). Anxiety-related attentional biases and their regulation by attentional control. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 111( 2), 225-236.
10	Eysenck M. W., Derakshan N., Santos R., & Calvo M. G . ( 2007). Anxiety and cognitive performance: attentional control theory. Emotion, 7( 2), 336-353.
11	Fernandes C., Silva S., Pires J., Reis A., Ros A. J., Janeiro L., … Martins A. T . ( 2018). Eye-Tracking Evidence of a Maintenance Bias in Social Anxiety. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 46( 1), 66-83.
12	Fox E., Zougkou K., Ashwin C., & Cahill S . ( 2015). Investigating the efficacy of attention bias modification in reducing high spider fear: The role of individual differences in initial bias. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 49 84-93.
13	Gamble,A. L., &Rapee,R. M . ( 2010). The time-course of attention to emotional faces in social phobia. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 41( 1), 39-44.
14	Garner M., Mogg K., & Bradley B. P . ( 2006). Orienting and maintenance of gaze to facial expressions in social anxiety. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 115( 4), 760-770.
15	Grafton, B., &MacLeod C. 2016). Engaging with the wrong people: The basis of selective attention to negative faces in social anxiety. Clinical Psychological Science, 4( 5), 793-804.
16	Heimberg R. G., Brozovich F. A., & Rapee R. M . ( 2010). Chapter 15 - A cognitive behavioral model of social anxiety disorder: Update and extension. In Social Anxiety (Second Edition)( pp. 395-422).
17	Hofmann,S. G . ( 2007). Cognitive factors that maintain social anxiety disorder: A comprehensive model and its treatment implications. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 36( 4), 193-209.
18	Judah M. R., Grant D. M., Lechner W. V., & Mills A. C . ( 2013). Working memory load moderates late attentional bias in social anxiety, Cognition and Emotion, 27( 3), 502-511.
19	Judah M. R., Grant D. M., Mills A. C., & Lechner W. V . ( 2014). Factor structure and validation of the attentional control scale. Cognition & Emotion, 28( 3), 433-451.
20	Kappenman E. S., Farrens J. L., Luck S. J., & Proudfit G. H . ( 2014). Behavioral and ERP measures of attentional bias to threat in the dot-probe task: Poor reliability and lack of correlation with anxiety. Frontiers in Psychology, 5 1-9.
21	Klein,R. M., &Lawrence M. 2012). On the modes and domains of attention. Cognitive Neuroscience of Attention, 11-28.
22	Lange W. G., Heuer K., Langner O., Keijsers G. P. J., Becker E. S., & Rinck M . ( 2011). Face value: eye movements and the evaluation of facial crowds in social anxiety. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 42( 3), 355-363. doi: 10.1016/j.jbtep.2011.02.007
23	Lazarov A., Abend R., & Bar-Haim Y . ( 2016). Social anxiety is related to increased dwell time on socially threatening faces. Journal of Affective Disorders, 193 282-288.
24	Liang C. W., Tsai J. L., & Hsu W. Y . ( 2017). Sustained visual attention for competing emotional stimuli in social anxiety: An eye tracking study. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 54 178-185.
25	MacNamara A., Jackson T. B., Fitzgerald J. M., Hajcak G., & Phan K. L . ( 2019). Working memory load and negative picture processing: Neural and behavioral associations with panic, social anxiety, and positive affect. Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging, 4( 2), 151-159.
26	Mansell W., Clark D. M., Ehlers A., & Chen Y. P . ( 1999). Social anxiety and attention away from emotional faces. Cognition & Emotion, 13( 6), 673-690.
27	Mogg, K., &Bradley,B. P . ( 2002). Selective orienting of attention to masked threat faces in social anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 40( 12), 1403-1414.
28	Mogg, K., &Bradley,B. P . ( 2018). Anxiety and threat- related attention: Cognitive-motivational framework and treatment. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 22( 3), 225-240.
29	Mogg K., Philippot P., & Bradley B. P . ( 2004). Selective attention to angry faces in clinical social phobia. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 113( 1), 160-165.
30	Moriya, J., &Tanno Y. 2011). The time course of attentional disengagement from angry faces in social anxiety. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 42(1), 122-128.
31	Morrison,A. S., &Heimberg,R. G . ( 2013). Social anxiety and social anxiety disorder. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 9 249-274.
32	Price R. B., Kuckertz J. M., Siegle G. J., Ladouceur C. D., Silk J. S., Ryan N. D., … Amir N . ( 2015). Empirical recommendations for improving the stability of the dot-probe task in clinical research. Psychological Assessment, 27( 2), 365-376.
33	Rapee,R. M., &Heimberg,R. G . ( 1997). A cognitive- behavioral model of anxiety in social phobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 35( 8), 741-756.
34	Redick,T. S., &Engle,R. W . ( 2006). Working memory capacity and attention network test performance. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 20( 5), 713-721.
35	Schneier F. R., Kimeldorf M. B., Choo T. H., Steinglass J. E., Wall M. M., Fyer A. J., & Simpson H. B . ( 2016). Attention bias in adults with anorexia nervosa, obsessive- compulsive disorder, and social anxiety disorder. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 79 61-69.
36	Schofield C. A., Johnson A. L., Inhoff A. W., & Coles M. E . ( 2012). Social anxiety and difficulty disengaging threat: Evidence from eye-tracking. Cognition & Emotion, 26( 2), 300-311.
37	Singh J. S., Capozzoli M. C., Dodd M. D., & Hope D. A . ( 2015). The effects of social anxiety and state anxiety on visual attention: Testing the vigilance-avoidance hypothesis. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 44( 5), 377-388.
38	Stevens S., Rist F., & Gerlach A. L . ( 2009). Influence of alcohol on the processing of emotional facial expressions in individuals with social phobia. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 48( 2), 125-140.
39	Taylor C. T., Cross K., & Amir N . ( 2016). Attentional control moderates the relationship between social anxiety symptoms and attentional disengagement from threatening information. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 50 68-76.
40	Waechter S., Nelson A. L., Wright C., Hyatt A., & Oakman J . ( 2014). Measuring attentional bias to threat: Reliability of dot probe and eye movement indices. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 38( 3), 313-333.
41	Weierich M. R., Treat T. A., & Hollingworth A . ( 2008). Theories and measurement of visual attentional processing in anxiety. Cognition and Emotion, 22( 6), 985-1018.
42	Wieser M. J., Pauli P., Weyers P., Alpers G. W., & Mühlberger A . ( 2009). Fear of negative evaluation and the hypervigilance-avoidance hypothesis: an eye-tracking study. Journal of Neural Transmission, 116( 6), 717-723.
43	Yiend J., Mathews A., Burns T., Dutton K., Fernández- Martín A., Georgiou G. A., … Fox E . ( 2015). Mechanisms of selective attention in generalized anxiety disorder. Clinical Psychological Science, 3( 5), 758-771.

研究	被试筛选	实验设计	刺激类型	主要研究结果 (SAD个体或高社交焦虑水平个体)
Gamble & Rapee, 2010	ADIS-IV	5000 ms, 以1000 ms为时间间隔, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是注视点比例	高兴、愤怒、中性	在前500 ms对愤怒面孔注视比例更高
Liang, Tsai, & Hsu, 2017	BFNE	10 s, 前2 s时间间隔为250 ms, 总体时间间隔为2 s, 同一面孔4个表情自由扫视, 因变量有首个注视点、首次注视时间和注视点比例	高兴、愤怒、中性、悲伤	250~1000 ms期间对愤怒面孔注视比例更高; 对愤怒面孔的初次注视会导致更长的第一注视时长
Fernandes et al., 2018	MCMI	1500 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是首个注视点延迟时间、首次注视时间和扫视时长	高兴、愤怒、中性	对正性面孔的扫视时长在0~1000 ms时间段内降低的速度更慢
Schofield, Johnson, Inhoff, & Coles, 2012	SIAS	1500 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 点探测, 因变量是首个注视点, 扫视时长, 从情绪面孔到靶子的迁移时间	高兴、恐惧、愤怒、中性	首个注视点有更大比例位于情绪面孔, 对愤怒面孔的扫视时长更长, 从愤怒面孔到靶子的迁移时间更长
Lazarov, Abend, & Bar-Haim, 2016	LSAS, MINI	6000 ms, 16张面孔自由扫视, 半中性半厌恶, 因变量是首个注视点延迟时间, 首个注视点, 首次注视时间和扫视时长	厌恶、中性	对厌恶面孔的注视时长更长, 但比中性面孔短
Lange et al., 2011	LSAS	500 ms和2500 ms, 16张面孔, 中性-愤怒和高兴-愤怒两种组合, 6种比例, 判断面孔组合效价	愤怒、高兴、中性	只有在2500 ms条件下, 当第一个注视点是愤怒面孔时, 首次注视时间更短
Buckner, Maner, & Schmidt, 2010	SIAS	2000 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 面孔-物体以1:3的比例呈现, 自由扫视, 因变量为注视时长	厌恶、高兴、物体	只有1500~2000 ms阶段, 对厌恶面孔的注视时长更高, 当总体而言呈现下降趋势
Garner, Mogg, & Bradley, 2006	FNE	1500 ms, 点探测, 因变量是首个注视点、首个注视点延迟时间、首次注视时间和扫视时长	愤怒、高兴、中性、物体	在焦虑唤醒条件下, 首个注视点延迟时间更短, 但首次注视时间更短
Wieser, Pauli, Weyers, Alpers, & Mühlberger, 2009	BFNE	3000 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是首个注视点比例、首个注视点延迟时间、首次注视时间, 扫视时长	愤怒、高兴、中性	最先注视愤怒男性和高兴女性的面孔, 0~1000 ms时间段内对情绪面孔注视时长更长, 但是在1000~1500 ms时间段内更短
Singh, Capozzoli, Dodd, & Hope, 2015	FNE	3 s, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是首个注视点延迟时间、注视点个数、扫视时长	愤怒、高兴、中性	在状态焦虑水平高时对负性情绪面孔的首个注视点延迟时间更长, 在状态焦虑水平低时表现为警觉

研究	被试筛选	实验设计	刺激类型	主要研究结果 (SAD个体或高社交焦虑水平个体)
Gamble & Rapee, 2010	ADIS-IV	5000 ms, 以1000 ms为时间间隔, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是注视点比例	高兴、愤怒、中性	在前500 ms对愤怒面孔注视比例更高
Liang, Tsai, & Hsu, 2017	BFNE	10 s, 前2 s时间间隔为250 ms, 总体时间间隔为2 s, 同一面孔4个表情自由扫视, 因变量有首个注视点、首次注视时间和注视点比例	高兴、愤怒、中性、悲伤	250~1000 ms期间对愤怒面孔注视比例更高; 对愤怒面孔的初次注视会导致更长的第一注视时长
Fernandes et al., 2018	MCMI	1500 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是首个注视点延迟时间、首次注视时间和扫视时长	高兴、愤怒、中性	对正性面孔的扫视时长在0~1000 ms时间段内降低的速度更慢
Schofield, Johnson, Inhoff, & Coles, 2012	SIAS	1500 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 点探测, 因变量是首个注视点, 扫视时长, 从情绪面孔到靶子的迁移时间	高兴、恐惧、愤怒、中性	首个注视点有更大比例位于情绪面孔, 对愤怒面孔的扫视时长更长, 从愤怒面孔到靶子的迁移时间更长
Lazarov, Abend, & Bar-Haim, 2016	LSAS, MINI	6000 ms, 16张面孔自由扫视, 半中性半厌恶, 因变量是首个注视点延迟时间, 首个注视点, 首次注视时间和扫视时长	厌恶、中性	对厌恶面孔的注视时长更长, 但比中性面孔短
Lange et al., 2011	LSAS	500 ms和2500 ms, 16张面孔, 中性-愤怒和高兴-愤怒两种组合, 6种比例, 判断面孔组合效价	愤怒、高兴、中性	只有在2500 ms条件下, 当第一个注视点是愤怒面孔时, 首次注视时间更短
Buckner, Maner, & Schmidt, 2010	SIAS	2000 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 面孔-物体以1:3的比例呈现, 自由扫视, 因变量为注视时长	厌恶、高兴、物体	只有1500~2000 ms阶段, 对厌恶面孔的注视时长更高, 当总体而言呈现下降趋势
Garner, Mogg, & Bradley, 2006	FNE	1500 ms, 点探测, 因变量是首个注视点、首个注视点延迟时间、首次注视时间和扫视时长	愤怒、高兴、中性、物体	在焦虑唤醒条件下, 首个注视点延迟时间更短, 但首次注视时间更短
Wieser, Pauli, Weyers, Alpers, & Mühlberger, 2009	BFNE	3000 ms, 以500 ms为时间间隔, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是首个注视点比例、首个注视点延迟时间、首次注视时间, 扫视时长	愤怒、高兴、中性	最先注视愤怒男性和高兴女性的面孔, 0~1000 ms时间段内对情绪面孔注视时长更长, 但是在1000~1500 ms时间段内更短
Singh, Capozzoli, Dodd, & Hope, 2015	FNE	3 s, 成对图片自由扫视, 因变量是首个注视点延迟时间、注视点个数、扫视时长	愤怒、高兴、中性	在状态焦虑水平高时对负性情绪面孔的首个注视点延迟时间更长, 在状态焦虑水平低时表现为警觉

[1]	JING Wei, ZHANG Jie, FU Jinxia, TIAN Lin, ZHAO Wei. Attention bias to faces in infants and toddlers: Inborn predispositions and developmental changes [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2021, 29(7): 1216-1230.
[2]	YE Youcai, LIN Ronmao, YAN Youwei. Tall trees catch much wind: Fear of positive evaluation in social anxiety [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2021, 29(6): 1056-1066.
[3]	FAN Xiaozhuang, BI Xiaobin, XIE Yu, HE Huizhong. Attention bias toward threatening emotional faces in individuals with high-functioning autism [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2020, 28(7): 1172-1186.
[4]	RAN Guangming, LI Rui, ZHANG Qi. Neural mechanism underlying recognition of dynamic emotional faces in social anxiety [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2020, 28(12): 1979-1988.
[5]	ZHANG Yali, LI Sen, YU Guoliang. The relationship between self-esteem and social anxiety: A meta-analysis with Chinese students [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2019, 27(6): 1005-1018.
[6]	LIU Bingqian, LI Xuebing. Cognitive bias modification of interpretation for social anxiety: A “bottom-up” intervention? [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2018, 26(5): 859-871.
[7]	YANG Zhou; JACKSON Todd; CHEN Hong; HUANG Cheng-zhi; SU Lin; GAO Ting. The attention bias related to fear of pain and its modification [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2016, 24(4): 547-555.
[8]	JING Yaqin; HE Siqi; HE Jinbo; ZHOU Lingling; LI Jing. The Biological Basis of Social Anxiety: Evidence of Physiology, #br# Inheritance and Evolution [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2015, 23(8): 1418-1427.
[9]	ZHU Yongze; MAO Weibin; WANG Rui. The Neural Mechanism of Negative Bias [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2014, 22(9): 1393-1403.
[10]	ZHAO Xin;ZHANG Peng;CHEN Ling. Attentional Bias Training towards Social Anxiety [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2014, 22(8): 1246-1257.
[11]	HE Jinbo;CHEN Changrun;HE Siqi;ZHOU Zongkui. Is There Lower Social Anxiety Level in Online Interaction? [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2014, 22(2): 288-294.
[12]	LIU Jingyi;HUANG Xiting;YANG Shuai. Three Components of Attentional Bias in Social Anxiety Disorder [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2013, 21(4): 664-670.
[13]	LI Tao;FENG Fei. Interpretation Bias in Social Anxiety: Research Paradigms, Characteristics and Modification [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2013, 21(12): 2196-2203.
[14]	LIU Hongyan;HU Zhiguo. The Facial Expression Processing in Social Anxiety Disorder [J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2013, 21(11): 1927-1938.
[15]	JIANG Jun;CHEN Xue-Fei;CHEN An-Tao. The Effect of Positive Mood on Visual Attention and Its Mechanism [J]. , 2011, 19(5): 701-711.