ISSN 1671-3710
CN 11-4766/R
主办:中国科学院心理研究所
出版:科学出版社

心理科学进展 ›› 2022, Vol. 30 ›› Issue (7): 1561-1573.doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1042.2022.01561

• 研究前沿 • 上一篇    下一篇

自伤行为的神经生理机制及共病障碍比较

邓洵, 陈宁, 王单单, 赵欢欢(), 贺雯()   

  1. 上海师范大学教育学院, 上海 200234
  • 收稿日期:2021-05-24 出版日期:2022-07-15 发布日期:2022-05-17
  • 通讯作者: 赵欢欢,贺雯 E-mail:hhzhaopsy@shnu.edu.cn;hewen@shnu.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目(19YJC190032)

Neural mechanism of NSSI and comparative study with comorbidities

DENG Xun, CHEN Ning, WANG Dandan, ZHAO Huanhuan(), HE Wen()   

  1. College of Education, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai 200234, China
  • Received:2021-05-24 Online:2022-07-15 Published:2022-05-17
  • Contact: ZHAO Huanhuan,HE Wen E-mail:hhzhaopsy@shnu.edu.cn;hewen@shnu.edu.cn

摘要:

非自杀性自伤行为(Non-Suicidal Self-Injury, NSSI),简称自伤行为,意为个体在没有明确的自杀意图的情况下,故意、重复地改变或伤害自己的身体组织,是一种不具致死性或致死性较低的、以自身为伤害目标的破坏性行为。本文主要基于近十年的研究文献,从神经生理层面对自伤行为相关脑区、神经递质以及与共病障碍的异同展开述评,并尝试建立一个整合性的自伤行为认知神经机制模型。
关于自伤行为的神经生理机制,综合以往研究发现,自伤患者边缘系统中情绪脑区的异常(如杏仁核的过度激活等)使患者可能产生情绪调节障碍进而导致自伤;控制脑区如前额叶皮层的异常导致其抑制控制能力受损;奖赏脑区如眶额皮层等的过度激活或许会成为自伤复发的维持因素;自伤患者疼痛感知区域如HPA轴的反应水平的减弱使其疼痛敏感性较低并主动追寻疼痛感。除此之外,相关的神经递质和基因的异常也是自伤研究领域关注的重点。比如5-羟色胺转运体其基因连锁多态区的短等位基因会减弱该递质的调节功能,诱使个体出现情绪调节障碍;又比如内源性阿片肽参与了疼痛和情绪调节的过程,且其水平会因个体早期挫折经历和遗传因素而降低,而自伤行为可以促进该递质的释放;同样的,在阿片受体被刺激之后,自伤者体内的多巴胺水平将会升高,个体对自伤行为产生愉悦感。
此外,还将其与自杀、成瘾、进食障碍和抑郁障碍进行了比较。自伤和自杀尝试者在脑电指标上有某些不同的表现,但二者从行为研究和功能成像的角度也呈现出相似性。个体的自伤行为与物质成瘾显著相关,且二者都伴随着抑制控制能力的损伤、阿片类和多巴胺系统异常引发的对某种物质或行为的渴望等。进食障碍患者和自伤行为存在较高的共病率,前者可能就是一种间接的自伤,且二者的脑电和功能成像的指标部分相似。最后,抑郁障碍也是和自伤行为有着较高共病率的一种障碍,部分抑郁障碍患者会通过自伤来调节情绪,且二者有共同的风险因素以及部分重叠的神经机制。研究以上障碍与自伤行为的异同有助于我们从不同角度认识自伤,并多方位实施预警和干预。
在此基础上,本文尝试构建了自伤行为的认知神经机制假设模型,将自伤的认知过程与各阶段起主要作用的神经生理机制相联系。未来的研究可以关注于自伤行为的性别差异、发展特点、干预以及与注意脑区异常的联系等。

关键词: 非自杀性自伤, 神经生理机制, 共病障碍

Abstract:

Non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI) is a major mental disorder whereby one deliberately and rapidly hurts himself/herself without a clear suicidal intent, but which may lead to severe damage to one’s body and mind. This review researched studies from the last ten years to examine the mechanism underlying NSSI from the perspectives of neuropsychology as well as for comparative study. Based on this research, we attempted to build an integrated model of the cognitive and neural mechanisms of NSSI.
Neural studies have shown that the emotion system of NSSI patients may not function well (e.g., over-activation of the amygdala), causing emotional dysregulation in patients, which in turn is a major cause of NSSI. Thus, damage to the control system, such as the abnormal activation of prefrontal cortex, may also play an important role in NSSI and may lead to the loss of inhibitory control, making it hard for NSSI patients to resist the impulse to hurt themselves. Meanwhile, dysfunctional reward systems, such as the orbitofrontal cortex, may attach NSSI behavior to relief or something good. As such, patients fail to understand that hurting themselves is a bad ideal, thus causing the recrudescence of NSSI. In addition, abnormal pain perception, which is related to the HPA axis, may also contribute to NSSI behavior by reducing the level of pain felt, thereby increasing eagerness for pain. We also discussed the role of possible neurotransmitters or genetic shortages in NSSI. For example, the short alleles of the 5-HTT gene-linked polymorphic region weaken the regulatory function of the transmitter and induce emotional regulation disorders in the individual. Another example shows that endogenous opioid peptides, which are involved in the process of pain and mood regulation (and whose levels may be reduced due to individuals’ frustrating early-life experiences and genetic factors), can promote the act of NSSI. Similarly, after the opioid receptor is stimulated, the level of dopamine in NSSI patients increases, and one may obtain a sense of pleasure from self-harming behavior.
With regard to comorbidities, NSSI had some partially overlapping mechanisms compared with suicide, addiction, eating disorders, and mood disorders. Self-injury and suicide attempts showed different performances on EEG indicators, but they also showed some similarities from the perspective of behavioral research and functional imaging. In addition, NSSI behavior is significantly related to substance addiction, and both are accompanied by impairment of inhibition control as well as the desire for certain substances or behaviors caused by abnormalities in the opioid and dopamine systems. Meanwhile, eating disorders and self-harm behaviors have high comorbidity rate. Eating disorders can be seen as indirect self-harm, and the EEG and functional imaging indicators of both are similar in part. Finally, depressive disorder is also a disorder that has a high comorbidity rate with NSSI. Patients with depressive disorder may regulate their emotions through self-harm, and the two have common risk factors and partially overlapping neural mechanisms. Studying the similarities and differences between the above-mentioned comorbid conditions and NSSI behavior can help us understand self-injury from different angles and implement early warning and intervention in multiple directions.
Therefore, we built a model that explained the cognitive process combined with the neural mechanism of NSSI, matching every step of NSSI with its neural bases, as well as presenting the neural correlations between NSSI and comorbidities. Further research may focus on longitudinal studies, such as building models that describe the development of NSSI; explore gender differences from a prospective of neuroscience (whether and why more women hurt themselves than men); discuss treatments for NSSI (whether there are any more effective treatment methods); and examine whether there’s a correlation between the dysfunctional attention system and NSSI behavior.

Key words: NSSI, neural mechanism, comorbidity

中图分类号: