ISSN 0439-755X
CN 11-1911/B
主办:中国心理学会
   中国科学院心理研究所
出版:科学出版社

心理学报 ›› 2013, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (2): 231-242.doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1041.2013.00231

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

民族本质论对民族认同和刻板印象的影响

高承海;万明钢   

  1. (1西北师范大学西北少数民族教育发展研究中心, 兰州 730070) (2陇南师范高等专科学校教育系, 甘肃成县 742500)
  • 收稿日期:2012-09-07 发布日期:2013-02-28 出版日期:2013-02-28
  • 通讯作者: 万明钢

The Effect of Essentialist Theory of Ethnicity on Ethnic Identity and Stereotyping

GAO Chenghai;WAN Minggang   

  1. (1 Research Center for Education of Northwest Ethnic Minorities, Northwest Normal University, Lanzhou 730070, China) (2 Department of Education, Longnan Teachers College, Chengxian 742500, China)
  • Received:2012-09-07 Online:2013-02-28 Published:2013-02-28
  • Contact: WAN Minggang

摘要: The simple understanding of ethnicity by lay people is called the lay people’s theory of ethnicity, two theories are used to interpret the ethnicity by lay people in their everyday life. One of the theories contends that ethnicity is determined by nonmalleable, deep-seated essence and the essence would give rise to stable personality traits and abilities across situations, this is called the essentialist theory of ethnicity. The other theory, however, denies the real existence of ethnic essence, ethnicity is a social construction that is arbitrarily created due to social and political reasons in historical contexts, which is termed the social constructivist theory. Some western studies have shown that people have different interpretation about ethnicity cause different group perceptions and group relations. It is necessary to test and extend these results in another social background, like the Chinese one. First, 351 students from different ethnic groups participated in Study 1. They completed a questionnaire aimed at assessing their attitudes towards inter-group perception, ethnic identity, lay people’s theory of ethnicity, and out-group contact attitude. The results showed that: (1) the stronger essentialist belief a participant has, the more sensitive he or she is about group difference; (2) essentialist theory affects people’s inter-group identity, i.e. the deeper one believes in essentialism, the tenser he or she feels about in-group identity and bias, the more passive attitude is hold towards out-group contact. Second, 104 Han students participated in Study 2. An experimental method was used to test stereotyping differences against the minorities in relationship to lay people’s ethnic theories. Participants were randomly assigned to read the article advocating the essentialist view of ethnicity or the article advocating the social constructionist view of ethnicity. The result illustrates that: participants in the essentialist ethnicity condition showed stronger stereotyped impressions, especially negative stereotyping than did those in the social constructionist condition, but participants in the two conditions did not differ significantly on their positive stereotyping. In conclusion, the essentialist theory of ethnicity has a great influence on ethnic identity and ethnic stereotyping. Practical implications of these results imply that lay people’s theory of ethnicity can be used as a vehicle for reducing prejudice. Specifically, we can teach people to hold more social constructivist belief and less essentialist belief.

关键词: lay people’s theory, essentialist theory of ethnicity, social constructivist theory of ethnicity, ethnic identity, stereotype

Abstract: 采用问卷法、访谈法和实验法, 考察了少数民族与汉族大学生的民族本质论、民族认同和民族刻板印象的特点, 检验了民族本质论与民族认同和民族刻板印象的关系。研究1结果表明:(1)持有强烈民族本质论观点的个体感知到的群际差异更大; (2)民族本质论影响个体的群际导向, 它使个体有强烈的内群认同和偏好, 但其与外群接触的态度较为消极。研究2结果表明:汉族被试持有的民族本质论观点越强烈, 其对少数民族持有刻板印象的程度就更大, 尤其是消极刻板印象。民族本质论对民族认同和民族刻板印象有重要影响, 在实践中可以将民族本质论作为一个中介, 通过改变人们的民族本质论信念, 减少群际刻板印象与偏见, 改善群体关系。

Key words: 常人理论, 民族本质论, 民族建构论, 民族认同, 刻板印象