ISSN 1671-3710
CN 11-4766/R
主办:中国科学院心理研究所
出版:科学出版社

• •    

次优食品营销干预策略的有效性探究:来自元分析的证据

刘红艳, 周泳含, 陈艳霞   

  1. 暨南大学管理学院
  • 收稿日期:2023-09-14 修回日期:2024-05-12 接受日期:2024-06-07
  • 通讯作者: 周泳含

Exploring the Effectiveness of Marketing Intervention Strategies for Suboptimal Food: A Meta-Analysis

LIU Hongyan, ZHOU Yonghan, CHEN Yanxia   

  • Received:2023-09-14 Revised:2024-05-12 Accepted:2024-06-07
  • Contact: Zhou Yong-Han

摘要: 次优食品是存在缺陷但可安全食用的食品,次优食品的商业化成为减少食物浪费的重要策略。然而,次优食品营销干预策略有效性的实验结果存在分歧。本研究通过元分析方法整合了目前次优食品营销干预策略的实证研究,分析了认知导向和情感导向营销干预策略对消费者次优食品评价和购买的有效性,并探索了营销干预策略有效性的边界条件。研究共纳入符合要求的原始文献32篇,57个独立样本共94个效应量。结果发现,认知导向和情感导向营销干预策略能有效促进消费者对次优食品的积极评价和购买意愿,具有接近中等强度的有效性,且情感导向营销干预策略的效果优于认知导向营销干预策略。此外,次优食品特征、营销特征和顾客特征等因素调节次优食品营销干预策略的有效性。本研究发现为食品相关企业营销部门和政府部门提供了管理启示。

关键词: 次优食品, 营销干预策略, 元分析, 认知导向, 情感导向

Abstract: Large quantities of suboptimal foods, which contain defects but are perfectly safe for consumption, are wasted. Commercializing suboptimal food has become an important strategy in reducing food waste. However, experimental outcomes regarding the effectiveness of marketing intervention strategies for suboptimal food have exhibited inconsistency. This study adopts a meta-analysis approach to review empirical research on marketing intervention strategies for suboptimal foods. It examines the effectiveness of cognitive-oriented and affective-oriented marketing intervention strategies in influencing consumer evaluations and purchase intentions towards suboptimal foods. Additionally, the study aims to identify variables that may impact the effectiveness of these strategies. In total, 32 relevant primary studies were included, comprising 94 effect sizes from 57 independent samples. The study shows that both cognitive-oriented and affective-oriented marketing intervention strategies can effectively improve consumers' positive evaluations and willingness to purchase suboptimal foods with a moderate level of efficacy. Moreover, affective-oriented strategies demonstrate a better intervention effect compared to cognitive-oriented ones. Factors such as suboptimal food characteristics, marketing features, and customer characteristics were found to moderate the effectiveness of these interventions. This study provides valuable insights for food-related enterprises and food policy makers regarding the effectiveness of marketing interventions for suboptimal foods.

Key words: suboptimal food, marketing intervention strategies, meta-analysis, cognitive orientation, affective orientation