Please wait a minute...
Acta Psychologica Sinica    2018, Vol. 50 Issue (7) : 739-749     DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1041.2018.00739
Reports of Empirical Studies |
Effects of prediction error on post-retrieval extinction of fear to compound stimuli
Wei CHEN,Junjiao LI,Jingwen CAOYANG,Yong YANG,Yanjian Hu,Xifu ZHENG()
School of Psychology, South China Normal University, Center for Studies of Psychological Application, South China Normal University, Guangdong Key Laboratory of Mental Health and Cognitive Science, Guangzhou 510631, China
Download: PDF(948 KB)   HTML Review File (1 KB) 
Export: BibTeX | EndNote | Reference Manager | ProCite | RefWorks     Supporting Info

Memories with a strong fear emotional connotation play a pathogenic role in a variety of emotional disorders, including post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety disorder and phobia. So how to fundamentally eliminate the acquired fear memory and prevent relapse has been the difficulties of clinical treatment. The retrieval extinction paradigm, which is based on the memory reconsolidation theory, was demonstrated an effective and promising way in eliminating undesired memories. The key of this paradigm is how to retrieve fear memory to undergo reconsolidation, which makes the memory fragile and labile. Research has shown that when a mismatch between what is expected based on previous experiences and the actual state of events at retrieval, the prediction error will occur so that the memory will undergo reconsolidation. In the present study, we change CS-US (conditioned stimulus-unconditioned stimulus) matching rules during the retrieval to manipulate the conditions of PE to explore whether the amount of PE is a crucial factor to open reconsolidation window.

In the current study, two tones and four colored figures were used, one of the tones and two of the figures (CS+) were paired with a mild shock to the wrist (US) on 50% of the trails, while the other figures and tones were never paired with shock (CS-). the skin conductance response (SCR) was the measure of fear. Four groups of participants were fear conditioned on day1 using a 50% reinforcement schedule, in such a way that they could expect the CS to be followed by shock every other trial. During memory reactivation on day2, participants received one unreinforced CS+ (No PE group), two unreinforced CS+ (Negative PE group), two reinforced CS+ (Positive PE group) and four unreinforced CS+ (Multiple PE group) respectively, following extinction training. On day3, participants took part in tests of spontaneous recovery and reinstatement of fear through re-extinction and regaining.

The results showed that the SCR was not significantly different among the four groups in the fear conditioning of the first day and extinction of the second day. However, on the third day, No PE group and Multiple PE group showed increased SCR in spontaneous fear recovery and reinstatement test, whereas Negative PE group and Positive PE group did not show any significant increased SCR in spontaneous fear recovery or reinstatement.

Our study provided further evidence that the behavioral interference during reconsolidation (retrieval- extinction) can effectively eliminate fear and block fear relapse under certain circumstances. According to the results, we demonstrate that the prediction error is a necessary condition of initiating reconsolidation and a lack of prediction error during retrieval will leave the memory trace in an inactive state. Additionally, the amount of PE is a crucial factor and too much prediction error will cause failure. It is inferred that a limited degree of mismatch between the memory and events at the time of retrieval will induce memory destabilization.

Keywords prediction error      fear extinction      retrieval-extinction      compound stimuli     
ZTFLH:  B842  
Issue Date: 29 May 2018
E-mail this article
E-mail Alert
Articles by authors
Junjiao LI
Yanjian Hu
Cite this article:   
Wei CHEN,Junjiao LI,Jingwen CAOYANG, et al. Effects of prediction error on post-retrieval extinction of fear to compound stimuli[J]. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 2018, 50(7): 739-749.
URL:     OR
第一天 第二天 第三天
习得3 CS+US 无PE提取 10 min 消退训练 自发恢复测试 1 min 4US 5 min 重建测试
3 CS+ 10 CS+消退 8 CS+ 7 CS+
6 CS- 10 CS-消退 8 CS- 7 CS-
习得 3 CS+US 单个负性PE提取 10 min 消退训练 自发恢复测试 1 min 4US 5 min 重建测试
3 CS+ 10 CS+消退 8 CS+ 7 CS+
6 CS- 10 CS-消退 8 CS- 7 CS-
习得 3 CS+US 单个正性PE提取 10 min 消退训练 自发恢复测试 1 min 4US 5 min 重建测试
3 CS+ 10 CS+消退 8 CS+ 7 CS+
6 CS- 10 CS-消退 8 CS- 7 CS-
习得 3 CS+US 多重PE提取 10 min 消退训练 自发恢复测试 1 min 4US 5 min 重建测试
3 CS+ 10 CS+消退 8 CS+ 7 CS+
6 CS- 10 CS-消退 8 CS- 7 CS-
[1] Auber A., Tedesco V., Jones C. E., Monfils M. H., & Chiamulera C . ( 2013). Post-retrieval extinction as reconsolidation interference: Methodological issues or boundary conditions? Psychopharmacology, 226( 4), 631-647.
pmid: 23404065 url:
[2] Beckers, T., &Kindt M ., ( 2017). Memory reconsolidation interference as an emerging treatment for emotional disorders: Strengths, limitations, challenges, and opportunities. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 13, 99-121.
pmid: 5424072 url:
[3] Bouton ,M.E., &Swartzentruber D ,. ( 1991). Sources of relapse after extinction in Pavlovian and instrumental learning. Clinical Psychology Review, 11( 2), 123-140.
[4] Choy Y., Fyer A. J., & Lipsitz J. D . ( 2007). Treatment of specific phobia in adults. Clinical Psychology Review, 27( 3), 266-286.
pmid: 17112646 url:
[5] Davis M., Walker D. L., & Myers K. M . ( 2003). Role of the amygdala in fear extinction measured with potentiated startle. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 985, 218-232.
pmid: 12724161 url:
[6] Díaz-Mataix L., Ruiz Martinez R. C., Schafe G. E., LeDoux J. E., & Doyère V . ( 2013). Detection of a temporal error triggers reconsolidation of amygdala-dependent memories. Current Biology, 23( 6), 467-472.
pmid: 23453952 url:
[7] Elsey, J. W.B., &Kindt M. , ( 2017). Tackling maladaptive memories through reconsolidation: From neural to clinical science. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 142, 108-117.
[8] Exton-McGuinness M. T. J., Lee J. L. C., & Reichelt A. C . ( 2015). Updating memories--the role of prediction errors in memory reconsolidation. Behavioural Brain Research, 278, 375-384.
pmid: 25453746 url:
[9] Fernández R. S., Boccia M. M., & Pedreira M. E . ( 2016). The fate of memory: Reconsolidation and the case of Prediction Error. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 68, 423-441.
pmid: 27287939 url:
[10] Garrison J., Erdeniz B., & Done J . ( 2013). Prediction error in reinforcement learning: A meta-analysis of neuroimaging studies. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 37( 7), 1297-1310.
pmid: 23567522 url:
[11] Hon T., Das R. K., & Kamboj S. K . ( 2016). The effects of cognitive reappraisal following retrieval-procedures designed to destabilize alcohol memories in high-risk drinkers. Psychopharmacology, 233( 5), 851-861.
pmid: 4751186 url:
[12] Ishii D., Matsuzawa D., Matsuda S., Tomizawa H., Sutoh C., & Shimizu E . ( 2015). An isolated retrieval trial before extinction session does not prevent the return of fear. Behavioural Brain Research, 287, 139-145.
pmid: 25827926 url:
[13] Kindt, M., &Soeter M. , ( 2013). Reconsolidation in a human fear conditioning study: A test of extinction as updating mechanism. Biological Psychology, 92( 1), 43-50.
pmid: 21986472 url:
[14] Lee J. L. C., Everitt B. J., & Thomas K. L . ( 2004). Independent cellular processes for hippocampal memory consolidation and reconsolidation. Science, 304( 5672), 839-843.
pmid: 15073322 url:
[15] Lee J. L. C., Nader K., & Schiller D . ( 2017). An update on memory reconsolidation updating. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 21( 7), 531-545.
pmid: 28495311 url:
[16] Li J. J., Chen W., Caoyang J., Wu W. L., Jie J., Xu L., & Zheng X. F . ( 2017). Moderate partially reduplicated conditioned stimuli as retrieval cue can increase effect on preventing relapse of fear to compound stimuli. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 11, 575.
pmid: 5714856 url:
[17] Li ,S. S.Y., &McNally G.P, . ( 2014). The conditions that promote fear learning: Prediction error and Pavlovian fear conditioning. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 108, 14-21.
pmid: 23684989 url:
[18] Liu T. S., Luo Y. J., Ma H., & Huang Y. X . ( 2006). The establishment and assessment of a native affective sound system. Psychological Science, 29( 2), 406-408.
[18] [ 刘涛生, 罗跃嘉, 马慧, 黄宇霞 . ( 2006). 本土化情绪声音库的编制和评定. 心理科学, 29( 2), 406-408.]
[19] Liu J. F., Zhao L. Y., Xue Y. X., Shi J., Suo L., Luo Y. X., .. Lu L . ( 2014). An unconditioned stimulus retrieval extinction procedure to prevent the return of fear memory. Biological Psychiatry, 76( 11), 895-901.
pmid: 24813334 url:
[20] Lonsdorf T. B., Menz M. M., Andreatta M., Fullana M. A., Golkar A., Haaker J., .. Merz C. J . ( 2017). Don’t fear ‘fear conditioning’: Methodological considerations for the design and analysis of studies on human fear acquisition, extinction, and return of fear. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 77, 247-285.
pmid: 28263758 url:
[21] Luo Y. X., Xue Y. X., Liu J. F., Shi H. S., Jian M., Han Y., .. Lu L . ( 2015). A novel UCS memory retrieval-extinction procedure to inhibit relapse to drug seeking. Nature Communication, 6, 7675.
pmid: 4510700 url:
[22] McGaugh ,J.L . ( 2000). Memory-a century of consolidation. Science, 287( 5451), 248-251.
[23] Monfils M. H., Cowansage K. K., Klann E., & LeDoux J. E . ( 2009). Extinction-reconsolidation boundaries: Key to persistent attenuation of fear memories. Science, 324( 5929), 951-955.
pmid: 3625935 url:
[24] Myers ,K.M., &Davis M. , ( 2007). Mechanisms of fear extinction. Molecular Psychiatry, 12( 2), 120-150.
[25] Nader,K. ( 2015). Reconsolidation and the dynamic nature of memory. Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology, 7( 10), a021782.
pmid: 26354895 url:
[26] Nader K., Schafe G. E., & LeDoux J. E . ( 2000). The labile nature of consolidation theory. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 1( 3), 216-219.
pmid: 11257912 url:
[27] Rescorla ,R.A., &Wagner A.W . ( 1972). A theory of Pavlovian conditioning: Variations in the effectiveness of reinforcement and nonreinforcement. In A. H. Black & W. F. Prokasy (Eds.), Classical conditioning II: Current research and theory( pp. 64-99). New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
[28] Schiller D., Monfils M. H., Raio C. M., Johnson D. C., LeDoux J. E., & Phelps E. A . ( 2010). Preventing the return of fear in humans using reconsolidation update mechanisms. Nature, 463( 7277), 49-53.
pmid: 3640262 url:
[29] Schwabe L., Nader K., & Pruessner J. C . ( 2014). Reconsolidation of human memory: Brain mechanisms and clinical relevance. Biological Psychiatry, 76( 4), 274-280.
pmid: 24755493 url:
[30] Sevenster D., Beckers T., & Kindt M . ( 2013). Prediction error governs pharmacologically induced amnesia for learned fear. Science, 339( 6121), 830-833.
[31] Sevenster D., Beckers T., & Kindt M . ( 2014). Prediction error demarcates the transition from retrieval, to reconsolidation, to new learning. Learning & Memory, 21( 11), 580-584.
pmid: 25320349 url:
[32] Soeter, M. , &Kindt M. , ( 2011). Disrupting reconsolidation: Pharmacological and behavioral manipulations. Learning & Memory, 18( 6), 357-366.
pmid: 21576515 url:
[33] Spoormaker V. I., Andrade K. C., Schröter M. S., Sturm A., Goya-Maldonado R., Sämann P. G., & Czisch M . ( 2011). The neural correlates of negative prediction error signaling in human fear conditioning. NeuroImage, 54( 3), 2250-2256.
pmid: 20869454 url:
[34] Xue Y. X., Luo Y. X., Wu P., Shi H. S., Xue L. F., Chen C., .. Lu L . ( 2012). A memory retrieval-extinction procedure to prevent drug craving and relapse. Science, 336( 6078), 241-245.
[35] Zhuang C. Q., Wang W. Q., Hu J. C., Zhang W. X., Wang P. G., & Zheng X. F . ( 2017). The effect of compound stimulus to conditioned fear extinction in retrieval-extinction paradigm. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 49( 3), 329-335.
[35] [ 庄楚群, 王文清, 胡静初, 张蔚欣, 王鹏贵, 郑希付 . ( 2017). 提取-消退范式中复合刺激对恐惧消退的影响. 心理学报, 49( 3), 329-335.]
[1] ZHUANG Chuqun; WANG Wenqing; HU Jingchu; ZHANG Weixin; WANG Penggui; ZHENG Xifu. The effect of compound stimulus to conditioned fear extinction in retrieval-extinction paradigm[J]. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 2017, 49(3): 329-335.
[2] DU Juan; ZENG Xiangxing; ZHENG Xifu; ZHUANG Chuqun. The Impact of Unconditioned Stimulus Devaluation on Conditional Fear Extinction[J]. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 2015, 47(3): 344-352.

QIU Xiang,FU Xiao-Lan,SUI Dan-Ni,LI Jian,TANG Yi-Yuan

. The Effect of Global Precedence on Mental Rotation of Compound Stimuli[J]. , 2009, 41(01): 1-9.
[4] Pei Jiantao,Shen Jiaxian,Gong Jianfei(Peychology Department,South Chian Normal University). A PRELIMINARY STUDY ON THE INFLUENCING FACTORS ON THE CHILDREN'S ABILITY OF MOTION DISTANCE PREDICTION[J]. , 1995, 27(04): 371-378.
Full text



Copyright © Acta Psychologica Sinica
Support by Beijing Magtech