道德概念具身隐喻及其影响因素:来自元分析的证据
丁凤琴, 王冬霞

Embodied metaphors of moral concepts and its influential factors: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Fengqin DING, Dongxia WANG
续表1 1-2
文献 样本量 文化背景 隐喻映射方向 隐喻维度 感觉通道 研究范式 效应值Zr
35 E S-T S V M 0.40
Lee & Schwarz, 2010 82 W T-S Cl Sk M 0.36
Nakamura et al., 2014 47 W S-T Te Sk M 0.36
41 W S-T Te Sk M 0.30
Fayard et al., 2009 210 W T-S Cl Sk M -0.03
Li & Cao, 2017 182 E S-T S V Sit 0.67
162 E S-T S V Sit 0.75
Schnall et al., 2008 40 W S-T Cl V M 0.30
44 W S-T Cl V M 0.41
Leung, 2013 75 E S-T Cl V M 0.27
Iachini et al., 2015 36 W T-S S V M 0.31
Zhong, Strejcek et al., 2010 58 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.28
323 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.15
136 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.18
Zhong, Bohns et al., 2010 84 W S-T L V Sit 0.51
50 W S-T L V Sit 0.28
83 W S-T L V M 0.30
Zhong & Leonardelli, 2008 65 W S-T Te Sk M 0.25
52 W S-T Te Sk M 0.30
Wang et al., 2016 24 E T-S S V IAT -0.86
21 E T-S S V IAT 0.51
Sekulak & Maciuszek, 2017 60 W T-S Cl Sk Sit 0.07
60 W T-S Cl Sk Sit 0.38
90 W T-S Cl Sk Sit 0.21
Denke et al., 2016 37 W T-S Cl Sk M 0.42
Webster et al., 2012 30 W S-T L V Sit 0.50
30 W S-T L V Sit 0.37
Lobel et al., 2015 30 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.42
147 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.19
Chiou & Cheng, 2013 54 E S-T L V Sit 0.28
58 E S-T L V Sit 0.31
48 E S-T L V Sit 0.35
Lee et al., 2015 105 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.16
90 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.63
70 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.24
Xu et al., 2014 65 W T-S Cl Sk M 0.48
Helzer & Pizarro, 2011 60 W S-T Cl Sk M 0.38
Kaufmann & Allen, 2014 40 W S-T We Sk M 0.31
Eskine et al., 2012 60 W T-S Sw T M 0.30
Williams & Bargh, 2008 53 W T-S Te Sk M 0.57
Steidle et al., 2013 80 W S-T L V Sit -0.25
58 W S-T L V Sit -0.34
48 W S-T L V Sit -0.31
62 W S-T L V Sit -0.31